35 points ivanmaeder 43 minutes ago 37 comments

aussieguy1234 31 minutes ago | parent

Hmmm...

I better back up my local AI, so I can keep my competitive advantage in case this movement takes off and actually leads to real restrictions.

reasonableklout 29 minutes ago | parent

Pretty sure it's about the bigcos and nobody will touch your local AI

oilkillsbirds 30 minutes ago | parent

It’s so simple, but nobody is going to do it:

Cancel your AI subscriptions, boycott its use in corporate, and stop buying from any company that uses AI. It’s that simple.

But nobody’s going to do it. See yall in the dystopia

ToucanLoucan 28 minutes ago | parent

I’ve never paid for a single AI product and I won’t. I don’t use my company Claude subscription.

It is possible. Easy, even.

Retr0id 26 minutes ago | parent

ToucanLoucan 22 minutes ago | parent

Didn’t say anything about just. I’m saying if you don’t like AI, it is extremely possible to not use it. I don’t and I feel absolutely not a molecule of FOMO about it.

defrost 21 minutes ago | parent

Results vary; "if everybody would just stop smoking crack" hasn't happened and will likely never happen.

OTOH, "if everybody could just help push the train carriage to free this person's leg" has happened, and will happen again (at least in my part of the world, as it has been and as it is today).

phoghed 14 minutes ago | parent

I don’t recall pushing the train carriage, must not have been everybody

defrost 12 minutes ago | parent

That's your best retort?

There's an interesting bit in the HN guide about steel manning responses, etc.

wat10000 3 minutes ago | parent

Getting a bunch of people to cooperate requires broad agreement on the goal and a sense that one’s individual efforts contribute to it.

Lots of people like using drugs. We might be better off as a society if everybody stopped using them, but that’s not a universal opinion. And one person quitting drugs doesn’t make a dent in the problem anyway, so why bother unless you want to quit for your own personal reasons?

Pushing a train carriage furthers a goal that everyone can agree on (very few people think it’s good to leave someone trapped under a train) and each person pushing can see that they’re helping.

AI is firmly in the former category. There’s nothing close to consensus on what the desired outcome would be, and among those who do agree, there’s no sense that individual action actually makes a difference.

knodi123 6 minutes ago | parent

> I don’t use my company Claude subscription.

So Anthropic is being paid on your behalf, but you're not using up any of their resources?

I bet you're the kind of customer they love. If only all of their customers could deliver such a margin.

amelius 25 minutes ago | parent

> But nobody’s going to do it. See yall in the dystopia

That's why the Amish will be the ones living in a paradise.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOfZLb33uCg

wat10000 23 minutes ago | parent

If I did all of those things, it wouldn’t make a damn bit of difference.

aaron_m04 5 minutes ago | parent

What would make a difference then?

rdbl27 10 minutes ago | parent

Unless you live off grid and source all your own food and energy, there is no possible way to boycott corporations that use AI.

eleventen 7 minutes ago | parent

It takes real bravado to describe a global collective action problem as "so simple". Anyone who resists AI at their corpo job is easily replaced.

cowlevel 7 minutes ago | parent

Boycotts don't work. They have never worked. They never will work. They can work in principle if 3/4 of a company's customers participate. That does not happen. That has never happened. That will never happen.

mplewis 6 minutes ago | parent

Don't forget to divest your entire retirement account.

uptrails 4 minutes ago | parent

Yeah. Techies are exceptionally well-paid, exceptionally influential, and essentially completely in control of their tools and trade. We just like to think ourselves as victims.

We created this tech, we championed it to execs who otherwise would have no idea if it's good at coding or not. And we kinda-hate it but also love that it now takes no effort to write slop design docs, create slop artwork, crank out slop dashboards, etc.

serhack_ 28 minutes ago | parent

the main question I wonder about is: why didn't any kind of anti-trust institution pose a stop about the big players of AI? I don't think it's much related to a stop about development of "technical" AI (e.g. research on LLMs itself). But I'd like a stop from them to keep mining my data/companies data and build the nth feature that look well-sponsored.

habitue 19 minutes ago | parent

Anti-trust is about preventing companies with dominant market positions from actively preventing new entrants into the market. It's not about preventing companies from making lots of money. It's not about making sure companies aren't too big. It's a really narrow focus on ensuring markets are competitive.

From the perspective of competition, AI is super competitive. It would be very hard to look at the AI providers and say they've stifled competition meaningfully.

amelius 10 minutes ago | parent

Isn't anti-trust also about preventing actors from making a huge pile of money by which they corner entire markets?

How about actors making a pile of money so large they basically destroy everybody's market?

cowlevel 5 minutes ago | parent

No, it's not about stopping them from making lots of money just in case they use it to corner a market. If they do use it to corner a market they can be stopped at that time.

Retr0id 27 minutes ago | parent

Do not accept autoplaying video elements

mproud 26 minutes ago | parent

What is this supposed to do?

theDoug 20 minutes ago | parent

On a practical level it keeps the speaking fees going for its featured signatories.

serhack_ 23 minutes ago | parent

https://iocaine.madhouse-project.org/ <- btw I'd support deploying this ;)

Axodouble 12 minutes ago | parent

Dead link?

cowlevel 5 minutes ago | parent

Seems so. It was some sort of Markov chain babbler with a bunch of hyperlinks back to itself, to swallow scrapers.

knowknow 23 minutes ago | parent

someone should make Do Not Accept Do Not Accept, I would sign it

hactually 21 minutes ago | parent

This is such nonsense.

The FLOPs proposed by their (and affiliated) groups is already lower than that used by the hardware for Opus 5.5 so what't the solution? Roll it all back for everyone? And how is it enforced - or is the brake just going on American companies?

I'm not entirely sure what the true purpose, nor the benefactors, of this effort is but it's not benign and it's not honest.

throwitaway222 16 minutes ago | parent

I'm happy with my two codex subs. Accepted

uptrails 12 minutes ago | parent

As I understand it, both MIRI (the org behind this campaign) and Anthropic are basically two sides of a religious schism that happened in the SF Bay Area rationalist community. Do I really need to pick one of these sides as they are fighting for political control over the technology?

bonoboTP 9 minutes ago | parent

> AI companies are deciding our future.

Who is "us" in "our future"? Why should I feel automatically on the side of MIRI (Yudkowsky's Machine Intelligence Research Institute, the maker of this campaign) as opposed to "AI companies"? Should MIRI decide "our" future? I guess this is the point where people would say oh no that's not what's meant, it should be "the people" who decide. Yeah "people" as the P in DPRK Korea, right? The people cannot act or decide like this. It's almost never meant that we should have some referendum because, honestly most people don't have any useful input to share on technical things. Then what, who remains? Self appointed NGOs? Politicians? Are they automatically "my" side?

hagbard_c 8 minutes ago | parent

Interesting to note that globe showing hardly any signatures from China. So what's up with that, only the Great Firewall?

These anti-AI movements are starting to look more and more like the unilateral disarmament movements from the cold war period. If the technology is as dangerous as the movements declare or imply, surely they'd need to get all development centres in on the action, not just those in the West?

trevithick 4 minutes ago | parent

But I'm told it's inevitable.