88 points ebrahimh 3 hours ago 48 comments

Rzor 2 hours ago | parent

I'm sure Rockstar is reconsidering postponing the PC release too much now. lol

turpentine 2 hours ago | parent

That depends how much the console exclusive deals were worth. Also, surely their lawyers can just pick up the phone and call Microsoft's lawyers to expedite the takedown of piracy attempts hosted on github.

drnick1 2 hours ago | parent

The project will just move elsewhere, nobody needs GitHub, it's just convenient.

ahartmetz 1 hour ago | parent

That is probably much more true than anyone on the not-illegal side of things is willing to admit in public.

ls612 1 hour ago | parent

The rumors I’ve heard is that they are targeting internally a Q1 release for PC and that is no doubt due to AI making a port/recomp/emulation inevitable on short timeframes.

onjectic 1 hour ago | parent

> Early. The game does not boot yet

SXX 1 hour ago | parent

There is no executable yet, but they can likely start work on generic xbox recompiler based off other games.

tomlockwood 1 hour ago | parent

All that's left to do is draw the rest of the owl.

staminade 1 hour ago | parent

Interesting to see how they're attempting to implement this. Basically a crowdsourced agent swarm coordinated via GitHub issues, where people claim features to work on: https://github.com/ItsNotRexed/Leonida/issues/634

arecsu 1 hour ago | parent

That's pretty creative

deklesen 1 hour ago | parent

The future is now

4b11b4 1 hour ago | parent

Wait what so everyone on some discord is throwing their sub at this? lol

bitwize 54 minutes ago | parent

Instead of crypto mining it's PR mining

therealdrag0 7 minutes ago | parent

I often have plenty of spare tokens on my subscriptions, so I’ve wondered about having an automated way to donate it. Kinda like how there’s CPU time donation tools.

superdisk 1 hour ago | parent

> Everything that can be done without the game's executable is in place, so work on booting can start as soon as one is available to a developer.

Glad they have the logo and name locked in before even getting a copy of the game.

ACCount39 1 hour ago | parent

"Getting a copy" is not as trivial as grabbing one off a disk. Dumping the actual executable involves breaking parts of console's DRM - they tend to ship encrypted.

So far, no one who did that has leaked the executable, or encryption keys, or something like "encrypted executable XOR decrypted executable" that would allow people to decrypt their own dumps.

But it's a matter of time. Either the Xbox side will leak, or the PS5 side will.

satvikpendem 44 minutes ago | parent

You're right but the parent is being sarcastic.

wmf 1 hour ago | parent

I wonder why they translate D3D12 to Vulkan. If the goal is Windows, just use D3D12?

SV_BubbleTime 1 hour ago | parent

Claude made a decision with the information it had at the initial prompt.

bigyabai 1 hour ago | parent

Because even with native D3D12, you're going to be re-caching shaders since your GPU isn't the Xbox's GPU. Might as well translate it all to Vulkan for convenience and portability, there's no good reason not to.

bakugo 1 hour ago | parent

Apparently the lead "developer" (vibe coder) on this is a 15 year old who doesn't realize he's going to spend the rest of his life giving half of his paycheck to Take Two.

SXX 1 hour ago | parent

They can scare this exact guy, buy they cant do anything with recompiler itself.

ebrahimh 1 hour ago | parent

This dev also led a similar project (https://github.com/ItsNotRexed/Hookshot) that targets the new Ocarina Of Time remake

Apparently this Hookshot project was forked into https://git.magicbean.dev/MagicBeanDev/Longshot because the codebase was badly organized (vibe coded)

whamlastxmas 1 hour ago | parent

This feels like some scare tactic by take two cronies

stefangordon 1 hour ago | parent

.

ebrahimh 1 hour ago | parent

Should have clarified, not my repo, found this linked in a reddit post and saw it had a lot of stars

just wanted to see people's opinions on it!

LatticeAnimal 1 hour ago | parent

That is obviously to avoid piracy claims, not to get someone to share a copy of GTA-6.

If they distributed Rockstar assets the repo would certainly be removed and rockstar could pursue legal action. As-is, this repo only enables people to modify their own owned copies of the game.

SXX 1 hour ago | parent

To recompile something you need decrypted executable that's not yet been leaked.

Supposedly someone might just drop one tomorrow or after tomorrow and this is why they want to prepare for xbox retargeting recompiler to work since before no one ever worked on one.

This ia much morw real than actual new playstation / xbox hack because for this "port" someone just need to dump decrypted gta 6 executable fron memory exactly once. Not craft reproducible non-destructive jailbreak,

rvz 1 hour ago | parent

I predict that this will be taken down by the end of the year.

So clone it before it gets a DMCA takedown.

hsuduebc2 1 hour ago | parent

I would be surprised if it last to the end of the week.

oh_no 1 hour ago | parent

it's not particularly usable now and will move elsewhere if github takes it down

GCUMstlyHarmls 1 hour ago | parent

radicle.dev though I assume they'll hit agent roadblocks too if not already.

DannyBee 42 minutes ago | parent

Hookshot (same dev,same type of project) got taken down but is now back up, as are forks (longshot, etc).

easton 1 hour ago | parent

This is based on a leak of the Xbox version of GTA 6, per Reddit.

I saw the file manifest and it looked like any other appx package, what’s the big difference between Xbox apps and Windows msix (modern) apps? Are there tons of custom Xbox frameworks?

jmyeet 1 hour ago | parent

Rumor has it that Rockstar has pushed up the PC launch to Q1 2027. For anyone paying attention, the PC port has usually come at least a year after the console release. Also, Rockstar has historically straddled console releases (eg end of PS3 going into PS4) so they can sell it twice. Obviously that isn't an option now because who knows when we'll get a new console? Maybe never given the advances in reverse engineering and how accessible it is.

I think of this like how piracy basically forced content holders to allow streaming of music, TV and movies. So I expect a PC port sooner than later and this is probably the end of the long-delayed PC ports, which I'm a big fan of. Rockstar isn't hurting here either. Even with an estimated budget of $1-2 billion, it's done nearly $4 billion in sales in the first few days so they're doing fine.

I know I'll buy it when it comes out on PC regardless of what pirate copies exist.

EA-3167 1 hour ago | parent

I think it has more to do with the fact that this time they had thirteen years and an unlimited budget to work with.

sudosysgen 50 minutes ago | parent

I think it's quite clear that the delay in PC ports here is almost certainly to allow for double dipping, as they think they'll be able to sell the same player the console and PC version.

robot_jesus 26 minutes ago | parent

Well, that and studios always get paid a premium for console releases before PC. Especially if it’s an exclusive.

lossolo 13 minutes ago | parent

I think it's mostly because the console versions weren't cracked, so if you wanted to play GTA V you had no choice but to buy it, unless you wanted to wait a year for a PC version.

kanemcgrath 5 minutes ago | parent

Piracy is a service issue, And I have not been serviced!

tamimio 1 hour ago | parent

Once it’s released to PC officially, modders will improve the game in a year what rockstar took to do in a decade.

mjmvisser 36 minutes ago | parent

I think it will be more like days. I never thought my skills would be obsolete and it’s happened in under a year. Claude may not be as good as the best of us, but it’s ten to a hundred times faster depending on the task.

qwerpy 12 minutes ago | parent

I'm waiting to get the game on PC until AI-powered modders have fully unlocked it back to the unrestricted GTA mayhem of past decades. Much of it should hopefully be trivial with AI. Remove the flags on X locations or Y NPCs that prohibits certain actions, add back certain NPCs that provide health benefits, enable unlimited room in the inventory, remove having to do chores to make an NPC happy, etc. Sometimes I want to just load up the game and blast everything in sight, or power through a game without having to do all the side quests to see all the content.

I'll probably be getting far more games on PC than on consoles going forward, so that I can bend the game to my will.

birdman3131 1 hour ago | parent

Why the hell does it need to scan your computer for where the game is? Two directories deep in every drive?

"It finds your copy of the game by itself: it looks in Downloads, Desktop, Documents, Games, your home folder and the top of every drive, two folders deep. It recognises the version from a few file sizes, without reading anything large."

Just ask me where the game is.

This feels like really stupid behavior and I feel like anyone running this is asking for trouble.

paxy 1 hour ago | parent

If you are running this (and any other similar cracked/pirated game or software) on a system that isn't fully sandboxed and airgapped you deserve what is coming to you.

bakugo 1 hour ago | parent

It's behavior that is obviously stupid in the eyes of a human. No human was significantly involved in the creation of this.

Onavo 1 hour ago | parent

Put yourself into the shoes of a non technical user and it would make a lot more sense.

It's a common UX pattern in game modding/piracy software. If you see Minecraft's MultiMC/PolyMC they have the same file scanning design. A lot of mod authors are vehemently opposed against their mods being distributed as part of a "pack" so the mod pack can't allow automated downloads of the mod in a compliant manner so they basically give the end user a CDN URL to click and then automatically pick up the mod once it's downloaded. The things we do to satisfy fragile dev egos. (And it's training users to have bad computer security habits)