41 points sammatilda 2 hours ago 26 comments

mabunday 58 minutes ago | parent

Everyone working on how Claude communicates would benefit from reading this.

xyzsparetimexyz 57 minutes ago | parent

Well surely claude struggles here because it doesn't '''understand''' anything.

rnd33 48 minutes ago | parent

Yes, this is often obscured when working with code because it's relatively easy to judge its correctness. When using Claude to write documents, describe a system or organize requirements it becomes clear very quickly that Claude doesn't really understand what it is writing, it just puts probable things close together.

Doesn't mean Claude isn't super useful though.

ivanche 5 minutes ago | parent

There are skills which try to force Claude Code to use Feynman technique like [1] and many others

[1] https://github.com/TheJavaGuy/tjg-claude-marketplace/tree/ma...

someothherguyy 53 minutes ago | parent

i have had plenty of people confidently explain things in a simple manner to me, but they have no idea about what they are talking about. humans and other entities do it online all day long.

nomorewords 48 minutes ago | parent

You have the correlation wrong.

"Everyone who understands X can explain it in simple terms" =/= "Anything explained in simple terms is done so by someone who understands it"

realty_geek 35 minutes ago | parent

Nice - clearly explained in simple terms.

qup 45 minutes ago | parent

If they have no idea what they're talking about, then they haven't explained anything to you.

catlifeonmars 41 minutes ago | parent

It is possible (although unlikely) that someone could explain something to you without understanding it themselves. For the most trivial example, you can imagine a television host reading something off of a teleprompter. I suppose you could counter that such things do not count as “explaining” though.

happymellon 14 minutes ago | parent

> The internet is a series of tubes [...] and not a big truck.

Sharlin 29 minutes ago | parent

Also, "explaining X" doesn’t mean "explaining Y, where Y is a poorly understood version of X".

nisegami 27 minutes ago | parent

That's the converse of the claim, which is (understanding something) => (being able to explain it in simple terms). This doesn't imply (being able to explain it in simple terms) => (understanding something) which is what you're considering.

rustyhancock 31 minutes ago | parent

I think the caveat is, simple to me might not be simple to you.

You need to understand the subject to explain, and the audience you're explaining it to.

psychoslave 2 minutes ago | parent

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=SxdOUGdseq4&t=346s&pp=2AHaApAC... comes to mind

And yes if some topic needs tensor or whatever abstract algebra structure to get it, there is no way to escape learning it first, though the way to teach it might be from tailored gentle companionship to a harsh read the dry book on the matter disconnected from any contextual presentation.

barrenko 27 minutes ago | parent

80IQ idea.

graemep 22 minutes ago | parent

CS Lewis, an academic in a completely different field (literature: Professor of Medieval and Renaissance Literature at Oxford), said something very similar.

Being able to break things down into simple explanations (maybe many of them though?) is a sign of rigorous thinking. Not being able to do so (which seems common in some fields) is a sign of the opposite.

tgv 13 minutes ago | parent

Explain to what level? E.g some topics common here. How do you explain NP in simple terms? "Things that are hard to compute?" That's simple, but not much of an explanation. It leaves the listener with a practically useless definition. And how do you explain even something practical as Heartbleed or Rowhammer? Etc.

And then there's another barrier, of course: the audience. You may use simple terms, and tell a lengthy story, but some things are hard to understand. Relativity and Monty Hall come to mind. They can be explained in simple terms, but how many people get them? Probably just the ones that also understand a detailed explanation.

trash_cat 9 minutes ago | parent

Simple for your audience to understand. Which means you posses understanding deep enough that you can explain it any any level of detail.

hk__2 6 minutes ago | parent

All of these remarks are addressed in the article.

cyh555 10 minutes ago | parent

Well if this applies to making softwares, then we will have a lot to explain, are we still shipping it or not?

lofri 10 minutes ago | parent

As everything, I think it depends. When the topic under discussion is complex and requires extensive background knowledge, it’s still possible to explain it in simple terms but the risk is to oversimplify it and loose important details. The alternative would be to analyse every sub-topic until the required knowledge is reached, but that’s no longer explain something in simple terms, it’s just delaying the proper explanation to when the audience is prepared to tackle it.

cedricddesigns 6 minutes ago | parent

In french, we have this sentence that sums that idea pretty well : "Ce que l'on conçoit bien s'énonce clairement, et les mots pour le dire arrivent aisément" Nicolas Boileau (author)

Frost1x 4 minutes ago | parent

I don’t think this is true because it makes an assumption that reductionism is always possible, you can always distill every increasingly complexity into something less and less complex and maintain the overall behavior. I don’t think complexity is always reducible because sometimes the detailed nuance is absolutely critical to the distinction.

You may be able to take core ideas from something and distill them but when you have multiple interacting core ideas you may not necessarily be able to reduce them to simple terms. And almost always when you do there’s a big asterisk that the analogy has a lot of flaws.

streetfighter64 2 minutes ago | parent

This was very satisfying when taking math at the undergraduate level, because everything was broken down into proofs from first principles, or theorems from earlier courses, so if you just paid attention you could discover how everything's built from the ground up.

Unfortunately the deeper into graduate studies I got the more it seemed that math "lost its way" and less focus was put on taking the time to really understand things such that you yourself was convinced of it working. Not just the proofs themselves but also the definitions, which often seemed to appear "out of thin air". Whoever pioneered the field probably spent years getting the definitions just right, but as a student we got served the final product with very little explanation of the technical details.

In that sense it felt a lot like primary / secondary school math where the teacher would often reply "it just works that way", which to me is a little disappointing.

bedane 2 minutes ago | parent

still wrong

some thinking and understanding is conceptual, spatial, bound to mind-muscle, smells, etc.

a good chef understands the ingredients' cooking dynamics perfectly and may still have trouble putting this into words

diamondDrill 1 minute ago | parent

yet to hear any explanation of quantum computing, that makes any sense....