33 points zerocool0101 1 hour ago 3 comments

raybb 49 minutes ago | parent

How are people liking Zulip these days? Every time I've played with it there are still quite a few rough edges but since they rewrote the native apps I suspect it's gotten better?

Unfortunately, I'm not in any community that actively uses Zulip so haven't had much real experience.

JoshTriplett 6 minutes ago | parent

I use Zulip every day, and it works incredibly well. There are still rough edges, but it's improving regularly.

The model of having threads within channels provides great organizational help. But also, these days, if you want to have a "general chat" in a channel that isn't in a thread, you can optionally do that. (I'd recommend not jumping to that just because you're coming from Slack/Discord and not accustomed to threads; give yourself some time to try them. But it can be useful for a subset of channels; some people like it or casual/social channels, for instance. I personally like threads for those too, though.)

Also, the integration and API are easy, and bots and similar are easy to write. You can also arrange to have emails turn into posts on a channel.

Despite what the site says, you don't have to self-host. The software is Open Source, and you absolutely can if you want to. But you can also use the hosted version, either free or paid, and save yourself the trouble, knowing that you can always move to self-hosted later.

I use the app on mobile, but just use the web version on desktop, in a pinned tab.

(Disclaimer: I'm on the board of the Zulip Foundation.)

l9o 6 minutes ago | parent

I use it every now and then when contributing to open source projects that use it. I mostly just use the web client from a browser. It seems like the macOS client is still just a wrapper around it so I don't see the point of using it. I haven't tried any mobile apps.

Overall it's a nice experience and I like how communication is more asynchronous like forums and not as noisy as something like Slack. The UI could be a bit more polished, but it's good enough.