50 points speckx 1 hour ago 22 comments
turtleyacht 1 hour ago | parent
komali2 5 minutes ago | parent
The Tragedy's original formulation is based on a false premise of land that was not Common but in fact had an owner who managed it. Overgrazing was due to mismanagement.
Meanwhile, land actually owned in Common has historically been managed very well, through informal techniques of social consequences for overuse.
The "Tragedy of the Commons" is usually used as a justification for more rigid management when the initial example is a false premise that indicated the opposite conclusion should be made.
Anyway this original article could probably just have been a Wikipedia link, but the question is right there: why should something be wrong simply because it's bad if everyone does it?
When we pull it apart we realize we actually had been doing the argument's work for it and engaging in a very normal debate about right vs wrong for individual actions. Example: what if everyone became teachers? Well there'd be no plumbers! No no of course we didn't mean the formulation to cover those kinds of things, we meant, like, bad stuff, like parking in front of stores! If everyone did that it would be bad, so nobody should do it. Well except for pregnant people or disabled people or old people... And so on.
verdverm 15 minutes ago | parent
dfxm12 14 minutes ago | parent
That is, of course a false dichotomy, but the guy parks there in the first place because maybe his teachers & classmates let him get away with bullying the new kid, maybe he shoplifts a pack of gum and no one tells him this is wrong, maybe he blows through a stop sign and realizes there's certainly no punishment if you don't get caught. This is why there's a famous saying, "The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing."
rexpop 3 minutes ago | parent
We don't need "cops everywhere", we just need the courage and social capital to stand up for ourselves.
Isn't that what your famous saying implies?
Here's another: "liberty is the mother, not the daughter, of order".
soperj 3 minutes ago | parent
You live in a world with both already. The cops just aren't hassling you specifically.
blini-kot 12 minutes ago | parent
hypfer 11 minutes ago | parent
Generally, probably good advice, but where it breaks down is that sometimes, what is sensible on the micro scale isn't on the macro scale.
Effective Altruism got the wrong idea there and pushed that way too far, but Kant alone doesn't work either in the real world.
It is however a good default to fall back on.
srean 10 minutes ago | parent
A torus ?
fwlr 10 minutes ago | parent
legacynl 7 minutes ago | parent
qurren 8 minutes ago | parent
When political and corporate leaders are doing things that make life hard for me -- taxing me too much, starting wars with that money that I don't want, wrecking the job market, not fixing basic infrastructure around me, doing things that make daily life more expensive -- I'll find more legal ways to amass more resources. Churning credit cards for massive sign-up bonuses, tax loopholes, free shit, quant trading to harvest more than my "fair share" of investment returns, etc.
When leaders are doing things right, I have little incentive to do these things.
kstrauser 2 minutes ago | parent
Basically, it’s not so much ignoring the rules as accepting that the rules have been rewritten.
bloomingeek 6 minutes ago | parent
I'm betting most don't think they're assholes, even if they cause a wreck. Nobodies perfect, but practicing decency is a virtue.
JumpCrisscross 2 minutes ago | parent
JumpCrisscross 5 minutes ago | parent
Loopholes are social slack. You can speed to the hospital, usually, in an emergency. If you’re running late to pick up your kid, sure, double park or streetside with hazards.
But if you turn this into a lifestyle, you’re broken. (Every person tweeting religious zeal for Jensen falls into that camp.)
dersch 5 minutes ago | parent
Maybe we SHOULD park in front of the doors at Walmart, if the alternative is walking 10 miles to the nearest parking place.
vrganj 3 minutes ago | parent