21 points parksb 46 minutes ago 15 comments

adrianN 28 minutes ago | parent

When AI agents can pass large parts of university exams we will soon need to examine the value of university education.

3asu5z 17 minutes ago | parent

If universities were independently funded and refrained from using AI, the traditional checks and balances system would remain. You need both a functioning academia and journalism to keep the oligarchy in check.

But many big name professors sell out as we speak, so the future truth will be dictated by ClosedAI and Misanthropic.

Any university taking AI money or allowing AI use should be defunded by the public immediately.

free_bip 16 minutes ago | parent

When AI agents can pass large parts of Kindergarten exams we will soon need to examine the value of Kindergarten education.

soco 12 minutes ago | parent

When cars can go long distances we will soon need to examine the value of walking (long distances).

lenerdenator 16 minutes ago | parent

I'd much rather deal with a human with the ability to navigate 4 years of an undergraduate degree than an AI agent that just happens to have the right weights for answering a question.

Lucasoato 12 minutes ago | parent

Or both, an human that knows his things and knows when and how to use AI agents.

lukan 15 minutes ago | parent

Or we need to examine the way we do tests.

c16 12 minutes ago | parent

You mean regurgitating information already readily available to anyone beyond the confines of an exam hall? Much more valuable to see someone apply the available knowledge (coursework + defend in person).

mschuster91 12 minutes ago | parent

Agreed. Whenever something becomes a KPI, there will be someone gaming the system.

And the last decades have shifted from universities being for those academically interested only to universities being yet another checklist on people's life plans, a mandatory hurdle to jump over, and on top of that a perfect way for (large) companies to shift education costs from them (i.e. the classic apprenticeship/trainee model) to the candidates themselves by way of (non-dischargeable!) student debt.

bluGill 8 minutes ago | parent

Universities have always been for those looking for a checklist - the rich noble kids needed that checkmark in Shakespeare's day. They let commoners (which itself was rarely merit based) interested in academics go as well to provide the next generation of professors.

fidotron 8 minutes ago | parent

It does depend on the subject.

This whole evolution of AI agents really is bringing into question which parts of the human experience are most valuable, and it's likely to become deeply uncomfortable.

pupppet 6 minutes ago | parent

Only if you believe the reason we go to school is to be able to regurgitate information.

mschuster91 14 minutes ago | parent

> South Korea is known for its intense academic competition, where job opportunities, social standing and even marriage prospects often hinge on which school a person attends.

To me, the solution rather is to get rid of this utterly deranged bullshit of a system...

DanielHB 9 minutes ago | parent

Brazil has a similar system and although it is brutal it is also one of the few things keeping rampant nepotism and elitism in check. Think about how it works in the Ivy league in the US, but 10x worse.

Only a big economics study can really analyze what system is better for society overall.

Truly the only way to actually solve this issue is to have a relatively low bar to get into the unis, but a high bar to graduate (so people filter out over the years). Sweden works a bit like this, but this is quite more expensive and the more prestigious unis still have to filter a lot.

turtleyacht 10 minutes ago | parent

Remember, just do a little better than average [1].

(Couldn't that have been done with hard work?)

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50503069