134 points lode 1 hour ago 72 comments

LPisGood 1 hour ago | parent

I think almost none of these ever worked for me. It’s a cool idea, but if it ever worked at scale, it would be shut down legally, and by its nature, it can’t really work not at scale.

ForHackernews 1 hour ago | parent

Shut down legally how? There's no law against telling someone else your password.

LPisGood 1 hour ago | parent

It’s generally a violation of the terms of service to share accounts like that. A civil issue, not a criminal one.

ForHackernews 1 hour ago | parent

Then the site can close the account and not send spam to that email any more? The operators of BugMeNot never signed any agreement with those sites.

I'm not a lawyer, but I believe in America at least we still have freedom of speech to encourage people to violate the ToS of websites.

RIMR 1 hour ago | parent

You don't have to sign an agreement to be found in violation of contract law. Knowingly advising others to break contract law is still a liability.

eli 54 minutes ago | parent

Encouraging someone else to break their contract violates what law?

delichon 1 hour ago | parent

The Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA), 18 U.S.C. § 1030, criminalizes intentionally accessing a computer “without authorization” or by “exceeding authorized access”. Abetting that would also be criminal.

rockskon 37 minutes ago | parent

And courts have narrowed the scope of what exactly that means greatly.

itake 58 minutes ago | parent

Criminal if bad actor does something bad and it becomes the account owner's problem.

itake 1 hour ago | parent

ToS / contract violation.

If BugMeNot is considered the "account owner", they may have legal repercussions for what bad agents do with those credentials. Just b/c you publish your email/password doesn't mean you're immune legally to what bad actors might upload.

ForHackernews 1 hour ago | parent

Yes, exactly: If I share my username/password, they might penalize me - not everyone I shared it with.

RIMR 59 minutes ago | parent

I don't think you're getting it, though. If you share your password through a website that explicitly instructs people to violate the TOS, then both you and that website could end up in court.

dotancohen 52 minutes ago | parent

Terms of Service are not laws. There is no legal penalty for breaking them.

tygon 32 minutes ago | parent

It is not a crime. It is considered a breach of contract in many cases. As a result, if a site can prove there were damages, they can sue in civil court for it. That is the big distinction here: civil liability vs criminal liability. It can be the former without the latter.

rockskon 38 minutes ago | parent

A company does not have a green light to arbitrarily decide what conduct constitutes a violation of the law.

Terms of Service is not a legally binding document.

eli 57 minutes ago | parent

It hosted credentials uploaded by other users. BugMeNot itself is probably not a party to the contract with the website itself at all.

RIMR 1 hour ago | parent

You're missing the point.

This site instructs people to violate the TOS of specific websites. That could land them in a lawsuit.

And the CFAA could definitely be interpreted to make this a criminal matter. I don't think that has legs, but it is a law on the books that this might violate.

lode 1 hour ago | parent

I used to use it all the time... I'm guessing about 15 years ago.

Most of the logins were actually bugmenot@mailinator.com, with password bugmenot.

lambda 42 minutes ago | parent

I've used it as recently as a month or two ago, though most working logins I found on it recently were just using throwaway yopmail addresses and I could just create a throwaway account with that if I wanted

salzig 40 minutes ago | parent

maybe we need to establish this, and maybe some friends can add this as a hidden feature in their project. ;)

bananaboy 31 minutes ago | parent

Same here, I used to use it often about 15 years ago but there was a period where the logins slowly stopped working for me and I eventually gave up using it.

randomblock1 1 hour ago | parent

Not much info on this page, so here's the Wikipedia if you don't know what BugMeNot is (er, was):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BugMeNot

lode 1 hour ago | parent

It was definitely one of the remnants of the 'old internet'.

I needed it today when I stumbled on yet another "create a free account to read this article" page and noticed they had closed. Checking the Wikipedia talk page and Reddit it seemed they had closed today.

mitchweaver 53 minutes ago | parent

I assume the long-term business model of a web site catering to freeloaders isn't great.

It wouldn't be a proper Wikipedia article without highlighting an obscure, largely irrelevant quote about neo-Nazis.

embedding-shape 51 minutes ago | parent

Not everything on the web has to (should) be a business.

mitchweaver 49 minutes ago | parent

Hosting costs money. Support costs money.

When your entire userbase actively go out of their way to not pay for something it isn't a harbinger of success.

Ads won't pay for hosting when all your customers are blocking them.

ygjb 41 minutes ago | parent

It want just about not paying, or was also about not subscribing to another service in order to read something.

mitchweaver 40 minutes ago | parent

Then don't read it. You're not entitled to free information. Those sites have hosting bills too. If you're referring to news sites, they have to pay the content authors.

Your registration is a quid-pro-quo in exchange for a service. Maybe they'll send you ads, or sell your email to spammers. It's part of the barter.

Back in the 00's warez sites called these people "leeches" — because that's what they were.

The "whateva, I do what I want!" reactions I'm reading here don't translate into the real world. It's not sustainable.

frumplestlatz 25 minutes ago | parent

I don’t care. If it’s not sustainable without taking my information, then too bad.

I’m not really sure what your point is, and feeding my personal data to a random website isn’t contributing to anything other than making the world a worse place.

I don’t even read my e-mail inbox anymore, it’s so full of crap from sites I’ve had to sign up for.

tourmalinetaco 15 minutes ago | parent

Simply put: I and many others don’t care. If I value a service I will provide benefit to it. I do not value, say, NYT. I don’t have an account, I use bypassers actively, and only read it when it is relevant to my life (less than one article quarterly).

Is that freeloading? Absolutely, but I have more important things in my life than worrying about their future, and I have communities I would rather support. It’s their right to block content from public view, and it’s also my right to circumvent their restrictions.

You can moralize and grandstand all you wish, but the real world proves that no business has a right to exist and that consumers will simply circumvent you if they oppose you.

ToucanLoucan 7 minutes ago | parent

Also as that other comment pointed out, the "ad supported" Internet struggles because so much ad-tech and ad placement is just... bad. Objectively bad. It's hawking subpar products, or bothering you to sign up for another fucking service to scrape your data, or it's a scam, or even in the case it's not any of those, odds are decent it's just a viral payload trying to get into your computer.

I'm sorry I don't have a single shit to give for websites that run ads running into financial problems. You tried to pay your bills by giving my computer herpes, go fuck yourself.

origini 11 minutes ago | parent

You are not paying for hn nor wikipedia.

Then you have monopoly and big companies like facebook which got rich by stealing/allowing stolen content, downloading books etc.

World is not fair and your website operator is not fair either.

rockskon 39 minutes ago | parent

I have zero sympathy for businesses that crowd out existing services with aggressive SEO and nuisance litigation and then demand people pay money for what wasn't gatekept before.

If a company goes out of its way to position itself as a gatekeeper then they do not have any moral high ground from which to demand people must pay any arbitrary cost they then impose.

The gall.

embedding-shape 33 minutes ago | parent

> isn't a harbinger of success

How do you define success? Providing a valuable free service for 23 years for people who couldn't afford otherwise, could have been exactly the type of "success" the creator was looking for.

Again, not everything has to or should be a business.

unrented7977 29 minutes ago | parent

Don't serve me malicious ads and trackers and I won't block them. This problem is extremely one sided. Users with adblock aren't the problem. Sites serving malicious and scammy ads are the problem.

pmontra 4 minutes ago | parent

A few days ago I used uBO's element picker to hide the empty spots where non adblock users have to look at ads. It was a motorsports site. One paragraph, one ad, another paragraph, another ad. I think it had seven ads. The page got pretty short once all the ads placeholders were hidden. I don't know if those ads were scammy but they made the site hard to read to me, go figure to the people that have to see them.

g-b-r 35 minutes ago | parent

Wanting to be free from tracking, awful people

afavour 23 minutes ago | parent

Very few accounts on BugMeNot were ever paid subscriptions. The vast majority (and my exclusive use of it) was to opt out of having to sign up for an endless stream of useless spam just to access something small.

Frankly, if you found your non-paid for site in BugMeNot then the failing is yours. You were gatekeeping some piece of content while providing no other value to users that might inspire them to create an account.

netsharc 21 minutes ago | parent

"Create an Oracle account to download JDK...".

origini 17 minutes ago | parent

It shouldn't matter to much if you have an account on a website to get content and watch ad or not.

You get just more valuable as the product if you have an account.

I'm lost though why you are defending here neo-nazis and pure capitalism shitting over privacy for selling more private data for more money.

dirtyoldmick 1 hour ago | parent

RIP

johsole 1 hour ago | parent

I remember using this website for various things a long time ago. It was very useful.

greggsy 43 minutes ago | parent

It stopped being useful for the things I really needed it for, but it was great while it lasted.

mopsi 1 hour ago | parent

Used it earlier this month to bypass Veeam's loginwall, worked well, saved me the time I would have had to spend setting up a fake account. Sad to see them go.

jodrellblank 51 minutes ago | parent

Used it recently to bypass pfSense login wall to download the free community edition installer.

They make you add it to cart, login, then purchase it for $0 before it will download.

(Yes I have moved some things to OPNSense)

sparkling 1 hour ago | parent

Forced Google/Apple/Social-Login, 2FA requirements and IP/geo-based tripwire security mechanisms killed the project a long time ago. It was wonderful while it lasted, thank you.

Legend2440 1 hour ago | parent

I think websites started cracking down on this, possibly because the logins were abused by bad actors.

When I first used it years and years ago, it was great. But in the last five years not a single login worked. This kind of thing can't really last.

BeetleB 57 minutes ago | parent

> possibly because the logins were abused by bad actors.

Isn't everyone who used it a "bad actor"?

Edit: People are getting needlessly upset at me. Look - I used to use BugMeNot all the time. I had a FF extension so I could use it. So I'm not trying to shame anyone.

But even as a heavy user of that (or archive.is, or whatever), I'm not going to do mental gymnastics around the fact that I am violating their TOS and am not acting in good faith.

Whatever your thoughts on the matter, it definitely does take mental gymnastics to think you're entitled to read a NYT article without paying.

4gotunameagain 54 minutes ago | parent

No. I refuse to create an account on a shitty website that does not accept disposable emails, just so I can download a manual for a device I own that was uploaded by some random dude.

Acting like their data is their fiefdom, while it is other people that provide the value.

RIP bugmenot

dotancohen 54 minutes ago | parent

No.

0x1ch 50 minutes ago | parent

Depends on who you're asking. The guy who wants to a read an article about his own town being paywalled or login blocked? Or the analytics team at THE BIG WIG TIMES attempting to get the best cost per click rate on their website?

writtenone 10 minutes ago | parent

> Whatever your thoughts on the matter, it definitely does take mental gymnastics to think you're entitled to read a NYT article without paying.

No. You want the information but the dragon holds it. So bypass the dragon and enjoy the information! You can enjoy something while hating its keeper / producer.

krackers 56 minutes ago | parent

It still worked mostly for smaller forums and such. I kind of wish they'd made it read-only instead, but I suppose the half-life of valid logins is only about a year or so.

tygon 38 minutes ago | parent

Once databases of known credentials spread, the writing was on the wall. Even with more modern options, many sites maintain a blacklist of known throwaday email domains, so you are likely looking at smaller, older sites this was still relevant. It is a product of a bygone time. RIP BugMeNot. You earned a good rest.

Moosdijk 1 hour ago | parent

I used this website just 6 days ago.

What a shame!

ktosobcy 59 minutes ago | parent

Bleh... IMHO it should be prohibited to require (or nag about signing up) for any "platform" content that is generally _public_ i.e. not limited to smaller group of friends/contacts...

It's beyond annoying…

greggsy 39 minutes ago | parent

Logins are mainly in place to deter scrapers these days.

Reddit in particular has become much more aggressive with login requirements.

BeetleB 59 minutes ago | parent

Had no idea they were still around. They stopped being useful almost 2 decades ago.

1970-01-01 48 minutes ago | parent

I used them to login to an auction just a week ago to see the bids. I guess I own the login account now.

1970-01-01 43 minutes ago | parent

There's very few (2?) alternatives it seems.

https://alternativeto.net/software/bugmenot/

krackers 35 minutes ago | parent

Technically only one since the first pulls from bugmenot as a source. The second one (password-login) does seem to be a really obscure alternative, maybe if enough people use it, it'll pick up?

noc0m 41 minutes ago | parent

Press ‚F‘

ohm 40 minutes ago | parent

How am I suppose to download VMware now?

greggsy 37 minutes ago | parent

None of the Broadcom logins worked. There are numerous Gists for downloading whatever you need, and they’re still easier than creating an actually login and navigating the website.

summermusic 18 minutes ago | parent

I used BugMeNot so much in college. It would never work for popular websites, but it had a very high rate of success on those sites that set up a single login for all students of a particular university. You will be missed.

Rustam_Khasanov 16 minutes ago | parent

Is it somehow possibly connected with AI agents hacking more services? was a public pile of working credentials simply too risky to keep online?

abixb 13 minutes ago | parent

In my handful of times using the service, I could never get any spare credential useful enough to put to work for my needs. Good riddance.

k0morebi 12 minutes ago | parent

I used to use it all the time back when it came out. Didn't take long for bad actors to steal most of the accounts (why do that???). Surprised it was still online.

Used their sister site RetailMeNot.com back in the golden age of internet deals. Haven't found a working coupon on there in a long time now though

Tepix 12 minutes ago | parent

Great resource, it often helped me and I was happy to contribute when it did not.

throwaway2046 9 minutes ago | parent

RIP... I used it many times over the years and even contributed some logins of my own. I'll miss it.