Yet another Hacker News

82 points soheilpro 2 hours ago 74 comments

ProZsolt 1 hour ago | parent

A 40% price increase compared to pre June pricing, a 60Hz display (that’s likely just software locked), and still starting at 128GB of storage.

I was actually excited for this, but now I’m going to pass.

sapphire4 1 hour ago | parent

128gb...

abhikul0 1 hour ago | parent

Thanks AI.

I wanted to upgrade my air(gen4) but with these prices it's just not happening. Oh and no support for the perfectly fine apple pencil I already got with it is just....

spolitry 1 hour ago | parent

Value/$ in iPad basically has not changed since 2022. Inflation (general and AI/antitrust-driven component shortages) has cancelled out technical gains.

sbdaman 1 hour ago | parent

Not in a snarky way but who is the target market for this?

thewisenerd 1 hour ago | parent

from previous [1] threads on the iPad Mini, at least aircraft pilots are a target audience

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19421163

criddell 1 hour ago | parent

They only sell around six million minis per year, so it's not a large market (for Apple).

tshaddox 41 minutes ago | parent

I predict it’ll be less than 6 million a year at these ludicrous prices.

adolph 45 minutes ago | parent

People waiting for >v1 Duo? Same processor, 1" larger screen, lower cost but you still carry a phone.

dkdbejwi383 43 minutes ago | parent

I've been hoping for a water and dust resistant tablet for use in the pottery studio for a while (for photographing work in progress, cataloguing glaze ingredients, taking notes, etc), as it's a wet and dirty environment, but the price kills all interest.

poszlem 30 minutes ago | parent

I can give you at least one group that loves them. Taxi/uber drivers who use them as bigger displays for their maps and apps.

sumnole 1 hour ago | parent

A bit disappointed it lacks ProMotion adaptive refresh.

comrade1234 1 hour ago | parent

I looked at the tech specs but I don't see how much ram it has. I ended getting more storage than I needed on my pro because it also gave it more ram.

SirMaster 54 minutes ago | parent

The 512GB option actually has a better chip with 1 more CPU core and twice the neural engine...

iAMkenough 34 minutes ago | parent

What does twice the "neural engine" get me?

For about the same cost, I can get a used M5 chip with both a Neural Engine™ and GPU cores each with Neural Accelerators™

nfriedly 47 minutes ago | parent

Gizmodo thinks it will have at least 12GB RAM, but it sounds more like an educated guess than a confirmed fact:

https://gizmodo.com/ipad-mini-oled-a20-pro-chip-2000830541#:...

animitronix 1 hour ago | parent

Oh yay, they made a kindle

criddell 1 hour ago | parent

I wish they would do that. I'd love a dedicated $200-$300 ereader from Apple.

jmull 1 hour ago | parent

AI Doomer: AI is going to rise up and destroy humanity!

AI Optimist: AI is going usher in an era of unparalleled productivity and achievement

The reality: RAM/Chip prices are way, way up. The starter iPad mini is $700.

kleiba2 1 hour ago | parent

The cheapest configuration of the original model was $329 in 2012 [0]. Even when corrected for inflation, that would still be less than $500 in today's money -- so quite a bit less than $700!

Is the comparison unfair because today's model is much more powerful than the one from 14 years ago? Perhaps. But perhaps it shouldn't be compared to the past, but to its relative competitors?

[0] https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2012/10/23Apple-Introduces-iP...

xattt 43 minutes ago | parent

Not really unfair, as the basic use case is still the same for either model.

A toilet from a hundred years ago in the same product tier serves the same function as one today. Old models were also more expensive when adjusted for inflation, but today's toilets can tackle more turds with less water.

HumblyTossed 31 minutes ago | parent

Oh I long for the days when every 2 years prices for compute FELL.

paxy 38 minutes ago | parent

How does AI explain the mini being $250 more expensive than the regular 11-inch iPad?

mrweasel 35 minutes ago | parent

> RAM/Chip prices are way, way up

So that cloud providers can have servers and GPUs sitting unpowered in warehouses and datacenters.

flaunf221 34 minutes ago | parent

> The reality: RAM/Chip prices are way, way up. The starter iPad mini is $700.

This has tiny 128 GB of storage and unknown but obviously not too high amount of RAM. At best 16, but probably less.

That's just Apple beeing greedy as usual.

spiderice 28 minutes ago | parent

Apple was "greedy" before too and were able to sell it cheaper. So obviously they're being impacted by increased storage/memory/whatever prices.

flaunf221 16 minutes ago | parent

More like they were not able to find a pretext to sell it for more.

I can open my local store and will see shitty 8/128 Android tablets for less than 150 euro. If memorypocalypse was the main reason for pricing new ipad mini as it is, the budget tablet segment would be completely dead because manufacturers just wouldn't be able to afford memory at all.

m3kw9 1 hour ago | parent

Thought China would have flooded the ram market by now

ChrisRR 46 minutes ago | parent

You can't just spin up factories producing top of the line components like RAM. It's an extremely expensive process

pizzafeelsright 42 minutes ago | parent

Maybe with enough money. Terafab ~ Q3 2027

sheepscreek 1 hour ago | parent

They should stop handicapping the non-Pro displays at 60hz refresh rate. The world moved on 5 years ago. It’s getting tiring now.

RetpolineDrama 49 minutes ago | parent

Right? Pro devices should be 240hz now

hbn 44 minutes ago | parent

The non-Pro iPhone 17 has ProMotion. I have to assume it's a matter of time before it'll make its way to the non-Pro iPads.

Insanity 40 minutes ago | parent

Sure, but the parent comment is saying the “matter of time” should be in the past. I wouldn’t buy a 60hz device today.

hbn 36 minutes ago | parent

If you needed a mini tablet you would cause there's practically zero competition

I bought the new 8 inch Alexa tablet the other day, and the price was decent but it's a piece of shit. I only wanted it for putting on a video in bed while I fall asleep but it can't even do that because when you drop the brightness to minimum, the display randomly turns off (not actually locking the screen, it's still running the app and active, you can touch stuff you can't see, but the pixels are turned off)

scrlk 43 minutes ago | parent

The base iPhone 17 has a 120 Hz display, I suspect they are going to drip feed it through their products as a cheap spec bump (vs adding extra RAM or storage).

HumblyTossed 33 minutes ago | parent

Or this will be an anomaly and they'll drop the base iPhone and keep the E model for the new base, the Air, the Pro and now the Duo.

mtoner23 41 minutes ago | parent

Has any non pro consumer ever noticed a display greater than 60 hz. I can barely get the regular people in my life to nice anything above 30 hz or turning off motion smoothing. I really don't see how any of this stuff matters for most people

scotty79 38 minutes ago | parent

You don't have to know what Hz is to see that scrolling on some devices is smooth and on other (coug..Apple) devices is choppy. 60Hz feels like a decade old phone.

qlte 23 minutes ago | parent

Yeah I wanted to love the form factor of the Mini and thought the 60 he wouldn't be an issue but was reminded any time I used the device.

Actually surprised to learn Apple did the OLED swap and didn't use the opportunity to bump it up at least to 90 hz like the OLED Steam Deck.

benley 33 minutes ago | parent

I'm sure there is a point of diminishing returns for display refresh rates, but I can tell you from experience that it is definitely higher than 60hz. 90hz feels meaningfully smoother (on a Steam deck), and 120/144hz (on a desktop monitor in my case) feels smoother than that. Even mouse input latency is perceptibly lower. I've never used a display faster than 144hz but I honestly would not be surprised to discover that one can still tell the difference well past 144hz.

60fps is basically fine as long as you are unaware that it can be any better, but once you find out you are forever spoiled by the knowledge.

lilbigdoot 27 minutes ago | parent

Yup. For me up until 90/100ish it's a pretty significant improvement all the way up and after that I don't know if I could notice outside of a fast game or wiggling the cursor over a contrasting color

I'm sure a lot of people now would feel odd if you gave them a 60Hz phone after high refresh has become so common, even if they don't pay conscious attention to that kind of stuff

lynndotpy 30 minutes ago | parent

I would be surprised if >10% of people didn't notice a difference between 60Hz and 120Hz.

Whether the hardware can keep up with Liquid Glass and push 120 frames a second is a different story, of course.

Aurornis 23 minutes ago | parent

High refresh rate displays are an interesting feature because most users do not notice the difference.

I can spot a 60Hz display from jiggling the mouse pointer for a second.

I’ve also done side-by-side comparisons of full screen scrolling on 60Hz and 120Hz screens for less technical people who could barely perceive a difference when I was pointing it out, but it took some time to get them to see it.

MKBHD (YouTube tech video and reviewer) talks about this a lot: It’s highly valuable to people like you and me who are attuned to the performance of our devices, but most people don’t notice. Or care!

I would appreciate high Hz displays everywhere, but I admit that Apple has probably made the right consumer choice tradeoff to compromise on refresh rate for these lower end devices where minimum cost and maximum battery life are the two most important features for those who buy them.

vunderba 5 minutes ago | parent

I think another thing to keep in mind is that there’s probably an element of sensory adaptation at play here. Like when you wear a watch: you notice it at first, and then you don’t notice it on your wrist anymore.

So if you’re actively moving between a high-refresh-rate device (like a lot of people here with their 144hz monitors) and then one with a lower refresh rate, you’re probably more sensitive (and potentially annoyed) by the discrepancy.

asciimov 54 minutes ago | parent

Goodness, Apple is going back to the luxury item category... thanks ai

xrd 53 minutes ago | parent

I bought a used iPad for my daughter for her birthday about a year ago for about $500.

M4 chip.

Her mom's cats chewed on the corner of the screen. It won't turn on.

The cost to replace that screen: $1200.

Apparently OLED screens break completely if just a single pixel is damaged.

ChrisRR 47 minutes ago | parent

I don't think that's unique to OLED. There's all manner of things that could've gone wrong when breaking a corner in both LCD and OLED

dreamcompiler 35 minutes ago | parent

That happened to my MBP without OLED. Fortunately I had Applecare.

gib444 31 minutes ago | parent

> The cost to replace that screen: $1200.

That's Apple saying to you: omg, stop being so poor and wasting our time, just buy another one

makeitdouble 8 minutes ago | parent

Only Apple can properly replace these screens and pair the parts (FaceId etc), so setting the standard repair cost high enough helps push people toward Apple Care eligible new devices, handicapping the second hand market.

That has been the case basically since Apple Care existed IMHO.

twidtwid 47 minutes ago | parent

$699 for 128GB is wild. Between this and HomeView apple has two meh launches in a row now.

cynicalpeace 46 minutes ago | parent

"We have released another mind-enslavement tool for your kids! It's the most potent ever!"

fg137 42 minutes ago | parent

> in an even thinner and lighter design

Never once did I hold my iPad mini with a case and think, "damn this thing is heavy"

deadbabe 33 minutes ago | parent

I thought the same thing about iPhones, then I got an iPhone Air and can’t imagine going back to those fat bloated bricks people lug around daily. Worse, they put a thick case on it making it even more portly, because the aluminum bodies dent so easily. iPhone Air is what Steve Jobs would have wanted: a super thin strong Titanium phone that doesn’t need any case to feel complete.

paxy 41 minutes ago | parent

I understand ram shortages but what is the justification behind selling the mini as a “pro” product? People want a smaller base iPad, that’s it.

apetresc 34 minutes ago | parent

In what way are they selling it as a "pro" product?

paxy 27 minutes ago | parent

By putting the A20 Pro chip in it rather than A16/A17/A18 which is on base iPads and iPhones.

dannyw 12 minutes ago | parent

One of my beloved devices was the Nexus 7, it was an excellent affordable template that didn't feel cheap, nor fancy or pro. Just a good media consumption / general purpose small tablet.

I wish Apple would make a similar device. I'm fine with recycled chips and getting a bit gimped on RAM size.

Like the MacBook Neo of iPads; I just really want a media consumption device. A20 Pro means nothing to me.

hbn 38 minutes ago | parent

Starting at $949 before tax (~$1050 after tax in most provinces) in Canada for 128GB

Zoinks

mrweasel 32 minutes ago | parent

It's the same price as a MacBook Neo

gib444 30 minutes ago | parent

£700 here (VAT incl). That's ~$1,310 CAD!

fletchdatpaq 34 minutes ago | parent

I would love Apple to actually make something that is worthy of the name Apple. When Steve was alive, Apple was A-P-P-L-E and now it is just a shell of its self.

al_borland 33 minutes ago | parent

I don't like when they force a storage upgrade just to get a matte screen. I have no need for more storage, but would like a matte screen. As a $100 upgrade for nanotexture, it already seems steep, but forcing it to a $200 upgrade due to a needless storage bump is too much to ignore.

I also question what is required for nanotexture. I read the iPhone Duo has this in a replaceable screen protector, effectively. A replacement, under AppleCare is $15. Are we being charged $100 for a factory installed screen protector? If so, why does that need to be tied to certain levels of storage to reduce SKUs?

scrlk 26 minutes ago | parent

Nanotexture on non-folding displays is etched glass.

hectdev 33 minutes ago | parent

As a life long and continuous Apple user (and iOS SWE), I recently got a $150 Samsung Android tablet that I can use as a claude interface. It can take in voice commands, and create new builds of itself on a network Mac. So I can essentially have whatever screen or interface I want for any given moment. Right now I'm tuning my motorcycle with an OBD bluetooth device and recording engine behavior on rides.

maromocooo 31 minutes ago | parent

The 60Hz display is pretty disappointing. The size is just right, though.

ksec 27 minutes ago | parent

They have enough bezel room to make it into 8.7" or even 8.9" version without changing the dimensions of the mini.

I believe this is the lightest iPad at only 255g. I just wonder how much more weight can they shave off.

And if they are going to kill the iPad? The current iPad line up is split into Pro, Air, (iPad) and Mini. Surely the mini could replace the normal iPad?

ChaseRensberger 23 minutes ago | parent

interesting this is so close to the iPhone Duo release.

rramon 22 minutes ago | parent

Is Stage Manager with an external monitor possible with this new iPad Mini or still artificially limited to M chips? I mean it’s more powerful than the M1 iPad Air which supports it.

breisa 21 minutes ago | parent

Whats the closest Android equivalent to this?