YHK - yet another hacker news clone

Wayland desktop for Linux with skeuomorphic design

686 points FinalDestiny 1 day ago 279 comments

uolmir 1 day ago | parent

This is very funny. But I think it would make me feel like I was working inside of Papers Please or some similar game.

ok123456 1 day ago | parent

Most people are to one degree or another.

PanicAdmin 1 day ago | parent

I see that this very bad idea is returning from the 90's.

brink 1 day ago | parent

What's so bad about it?

exe34 1 day ago | parent

He doesn't like it.

austinthetaco 1 day ago | parent

I reckon a lot of the people clamoring for these things are gen z or younger first discovering the idea of customizable OS's and are now going through all the awful decisions that were made before. Pretty sure I've seen a version of this skeuomorphic desktop like 15 times at this point.

ChrisMarshallNY 1 day ago | parent

In the last century, there was an app for Apple's Mac OS (before MacOSX), called Kaleidoscope[0]. It allowed massive customization.

Fun, but most themes were basically unusable.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaleidoscope_(software)

Some samples: https://web.archive.org/web/20110709175639fw_/http://www.kal...

(The one I used the most, was Ozymandias II).

chihuahua 1 day ago | parent

The children yearn for Microsoft Bob - which took this idea a bit further:

"Microsoft Bob presented screens showing a house, with rooms that the user could visit containing familiar objects corresponding to computer applications, such as a desk with pen and paper and a checkbook. Clicking on the pen and paper would open the system's word processor."

al_borland 1 day ago | parent

Some level of skeuomorphic design is quite nice, like what we saw from Apple during the Forstall era. It seemed to strike a good balance.

Something like Microsoft BOB takes the metaphor too far and gets weird.

I think this project leans on it a little too hard, but a balanced approach can make the systems quite charming and provide a nice juxtaposition to the very austere hardware we have these days.

ChrisMarshallNY 1 day ago | parent

Personally, I found skeuomorphic design to be something that I really enjoyed, for a couple of days, but rapidly got sick of.

That may have more to with the skills of the implementors, as opposed to the concept, as a whole.

I do find modern "flat" design to be less "fun," but I get a lot more done with it.

sixothree 1 day ago | parent

That might be the thing. In real life you don't use the same stationary for years. Your desk is a reflection of your mood and evolves almost daily. Maybe that's where these fail?

warkdarrior 1 day ago | parent

Indeed, my mood most days is bland, monotonic, and flat, just like my desktop.

al_borland 1 day ago | parent

This is where themes come in.

Telaneo 1 day ago | parent

> In real life you don't use the same stationary for years.

That's honestly just because I can't reuse paper I've already written something on. That's a limitation of paper I'm glad the digital did away with.

I've used some pens for years. Once I found one I liked, I stuck with it.

I switched to Linux to get away from the UI churn. Things changing without my consent does not bring me joy, but it's not like you really have a choice if you run Windows (or a distro with a DE that does do the churn).

sixothree 1 day ago | parent

You point is?

Telaneo 1 day ago | parent

I functionally do use the same stationary for years. The only exception is paper, which I try to avoid using due to its real world limitaions. My desk doesn't change depending on my mood. It barely develops yearly, let alone daily.

tty456 1 day ago | parent

Why's it bad?

seemaze 1 day ago | parent

Man, first Felix Reiseberg[0], then OpenCode 2.0[1], and now this in the last 24 hrs. Really giving off heavy Myst vibes. They are briefly interesting encounters, buy I deeply hope this isn't a legitimate UI trend.

It's hardly even skeuomorphism, it's a almost digital twin rendered with Phong.

[0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50082470

[1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50094994

oriettaxx 1 day ago | parent

Felix Rieseberg

tmtvl 1 day ago | parent

No idea why you're being downvoted, your correction is correct.

oriettaxx 1 day ago | parent

it happens pretty often: that "xx" in my username probably does not help

ranger_danger 1 day ago | parent

Yes! Please bring back the soul we had with retro OS GUIs (and the speed)... it's time for a resurgence. Especially with new systems/RAM/GPUs/etc. not being a thing for quite a while for a lot of people now.

RugnirViking 1 day ago | parent

the "paper windows" idea doesn't seem to have been done with as much soul as the rest of the ui. Just a turned up corner. I reckon something done there could really tie this together

alehlopeh 1 day ago | parent

A “dog-eared corner” in fact. The readme is painful to read if you have an aversion to Claude prose.

Retr0id 1 day ago | parent

fwiw that is the standard term for that kind of fold (to the extent that it has its own wikipedia article), but I agree that the claude prose is gross.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dog_ears

lelanthran 1 day ago | parent

I only skimmed the README, but I didn't notice any Claudisms.

I could read it comfortably, whereas usually I can't make it through even a paragraph from an LLM.

Retr0id 1 day ago | parent

It's chock full of Claudisms!

> The room is ray-traced, and one desk lamp lights all of it.

> The first login draws the room once: a few seconds on a GPU, longer without one. After that it starts at once.

> Nothing here is a symbol for a thing on a desk.

> each is drawn to look like the real thing set down there

I could go on...

esperent 1 day ago | parent

I love this, at least from the screenshots. I'll test it out tomorrow. I hope this kind of design makes a comeback.

acheron 1 day ago | parent

Fantastic. Giving me memories of MS Bob. Put a talking animal assistant in the corner and you’ve got it. Oh, and you could connect the assistant to an LLM of course.

cogman10 1 day ago | parent

Exactly what it reminded me of. Although a lot more functional.

WorldMaker 1 day ago | parent

But a lot less coherent personality. Bob had a somewhat coherent cartoon world aesthetic. This just looks like "TEMU Myst" to me.

nntwozz 1 day ago | parent

Flashback to TabWorks.

Compaq Presario 486 1994, I was 10.

And yes, played Myst on it.

Tempus fugit…

xbar 1 day ago | parent

Did it have that tiny rollerball on the side?

We bought a bunch of TabWorks-based Compaqs back then for a medical office where I was doing IT work. I thought it was slick at the time.

probablyStimmed 1 day ago | parent

And did it have a Quantum Bigfoot hdd in it that you could never use again because of its size?

nntwozz 1 day ago | parent

I specifically remember having 420 MiB, dunno anything else.

nntwozz 1 day ago | parent

Just mouse, bought a Logitech 3 button later.

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Logitech_3_buttons_m...

dobin 1 day ago | parent

I had it too on a Compaq Presario 90Mhz pentium multimedia machine.

One of my first contacts with a GUI. Windows 3.1 was the default, and soon Windows 95 was the "better" desktop.

But looking back, TabWorks was pretty cool and useful.

iamnothere 1 day ago | parent

This is neat, it’s not for me (I prefer extreme minimalism) but I could see how some would prefer it. I like how we’re getting more desktop options now thanks to wlroots.

bovermyer 1 day ago | parent

I love this. Hopefully we start to see more experiments like this.

cr125rider 1 day ago | parent

I like when designers are creative.

brink 1 day ago | parent

This is lovely. I really hope society returns to chasing beauty again. We need it.

2OEH8eoCRo0 1 day ago | parent

But will this make a billion dollars and let me force my bizarre beliefs on the world?

brink 1 day ago | parent

Agreed. Greed is consuming everything before our eyes.

hobo123 1 day ago | parent

The same thing we do every day, Pinky.

xbar 1 day ago | parent

Love it. Maximize skeuomorphic design.

bmurphy1976 1 day ago | parent

I want more stuff like this. The era 20 years ago (e.g. Enlightenment) was way more fun than the bland monotonic design we have these days. If you like bland modern design, great, that should be an option as well, but we should still have good variety.

anonzzzies 1 day ago | parent

I look back at my Enlightenment desktop with joy. I guess many people hated all the tinkering with drivers & settings etc, but I loved it. Spending a few weekends getting a computer running with Linux and Enlightenment exactly like I wanted it to and then actually using that as my main driver for years are very nice memories.

lelanthran 1 day ago | parent

> Spending a few weekends getting a computer running with Linux and Enlightenment exactly like I wanted it to and then actually using that as my main driver for years are very nice memories.

Years? The novelty wore off in a week with Enlightenment's constant crashing :-(

Anyway, I look forward to more Window Managers (Hell, even a whole DE) that put the fun and whimsy back into computing.

seba_dos1 1 day ago | parent

I used to use e17 on my daily driver phone. Illume was a nice UI, but you (or your distro) did have to find a good revision to not have it crash indeed :)

lelanthran 1 day ago | parent

My distro was Slackware, prior to any sort of package management, so, yeah, things would crash, but IIRC, Enlightenment, as much as I loved the use, look and feel, just crashed way too often.

seba_dos1 1 day ago | parent

   *** Eina Magic Check Failed !!!
       Input handle pointer is NULL !
   *** NAUGHTY PROGRAMMER!!!
   *** SPANK SPANK SPANK!!!
   *** Now go fix your code. Tut tut tut!

Symbiote 1 day ago | parent

What stops you from using it now?

Sohcahtoa82 1 day ago | parent

> If you like bland modern design, great,

I don't know why anybody would. It takes all the lessons we learned about UX from user testing in the late 90s/early 00s and throws it all away to produce something that looks "clean" and "sleek", at the cost of being useful. Discoverability? Who needs it?

EDIT: Though I do enjoy skeuomorphism, I do think the TFA goes a bit too far.

Zigurd 1 day ago | parent

Debatable. IIRC Bell labs conducted a study of whether Unix command names should be changed to something more meaningful than cat, sed, grep etc.

They found that words that convey some meaning related to what the command does had little or no effect on the user remembering what the command does. I strongly suspect skeuomorphism similarly has no claim on functional advantage.

Discoverability is good, but it's probably got a little to do with the icon.

lelanthran 1 day ago | parent

> I strongly suspect skeuomorphism similarly has no claim on functional advantage.

I think it does, but for new users only. I hate playing the "is-this-a-button" on modern designs, not knowing what is clickable and what is not. Other games I hate:

- Lets find the scrollbar

- Guess which window has focus

- (Windows-only) Try to predict the application to get focus on alt-tab, then alt-tab again.

- How do I find the file that just downloaded?

mcv 1 day ago | parent

Absolutely. I keep falling into these traps. I just got a Mac, and it's terrible at these. It's notorious for hiding the scrollbar, but why would they make it hard to find the thing I just downloaded? Or a screenshot I just took? I can open it, but that doesn't take me to the file location so I can actually do something with it. Although Steam is by far the worst at that.

It's almost as if we didn't learn anything about UX in the past 30 years.

andai 1 day ago | parent

UX was mastered 31 years ago. The intervening years have been a nosedive.

Fr0styMatt88 1 day ago | parent

What do you mean about Steam?

mcv 1 day ago | parent

Steam screenshots end up somewhere deep in the steam folder structure. Not simply in an easily accessible downloads or screenshots directory in my home dir.

wolvoleo 1 day ago | parent

What I hate most about mac is the opinionated design. I liked it in the days of Tiger and Leopard but what I didn't like since was some designer deciding that I have to use my computer in a different way every year and forcing changes on me. Opinionated design only works when you as a user have no opinions or if you are a follower.

Personally I do have strong opinions how my computer should work and I'm not a follower. I could never work in an army and take orders either.

The problem was that early OS X used to be pretty aligned with my own opinions so I didn't notice the issues with this model. But after the Mac becoming more frustrating every year I finally dumped it and now I'm really happy with KDE which I can configure how I want.

jmb99 1 day ago | parent

> why would they make it hard to find the thing I just downloaded?

In… the downloads folder? How much more obvious does the location need to be?

nottorp 21 hours ago | parent

You can also drag the downloads and desktop folders to the dock, sort the resulting lists by date added and then you always have your latest screenshot and downloads handy.

red_admiral 1 day ago | parent

> Guess which window has focus

Used to be a solved problem before some ** messed it up. I hate that game too.

WesolyKubeczek 1 day ago | parent

- Should there even be a scrollbar?

Many apps present content in such a way that makes it impossible to tell if there is anything more on the screen until you actually try to scroll. The home screen of the app is so clean and so fitted that there is nothing poking out from the bottom.

dylan604 1 day ago | parent

oh gawd, please please please do not interpret this as pagination of windows with overflowing content!

the image carousel type dots or similar old skool pagination indicators are so much worse than a simple scroll bar.

santoshalper 1 day ago | parent

Yeah, those are all legit gripes about modern operating system UX, but none of them are automatically fixed with skeuomorphism, and none of them couldn't be fixed with clearer design regardless of approach.

Sohcahtoa82 1 day ago | parent

> none of them are automatically fixed with skeuomorphism

True.

But they absolutely need to stop hiding functionality in order to present a "clean" interface.

Sure, I've seen some cluttered interfaces. I recently launched LibreOffice Calc and damn there were a lot of buttons on that toolbar (I may be using an insanely old version).

But like...disappearing scrollbars makes zero sense and should never have been implemented on any interface.

dylan604 1 day ago | parent

> disappearing scrollbars makes zero sense and should never have been implemented on any interface.

My biggest gripe about the disappearing scrollbars is the layout shifting that can occur when the content changes making the scrollbar necessary or not. CSS has a few options that can take care of that, but it requires some digging for someone to discover them.

tavavex 1 day ago | parent

A lot of these don't need skeuomorphism to be solved. It just needs clearer designs. Always showing vital elements like the scrollbar isn't a skeuomorphic choice, it's always a good idea, they only started hiding them because it looked 'cleaner' to some UI designer. The same with using color to show window focus, separate distinct elements or foreground from background. Nowadays everything is just white, but this is just a product of visual design trends, not (anti)skeuomorphism.

setopt 1 day ago | parent

> Always showing vital elements like the scrollbar isn't a skeuomorphic choice, it's always a good idea, they only started hiding them because it looked 'cleaner' to some UI designer.

There’s a lot of modern design in not happy with, but this is not personally one of them. If I can’t autohide scrollbars I try to turn them permanently off instead of permanently on. For some reason I find them very distracting, and since I anyway use a scroll wheel or trackpad or keybindings, I don’t need it to scroll. (If it’s on autohide, I use it as a progress bar when actually scrolling.).

But there’s a lot of these weird things that seemingly everyone else accepts that just really throws off my focus. Blinking text cursor is another one, I just can’t get any work done until the blinking is off. If an app or OS can’t do that, I won’t use it.

thwarted 1 day ago | parent

> they only started hiding them because it looked 'cleaner' to some UI designer.

They started doing it on mobile in order to give more screen real estate to the content area. This was then translated to desktop apps at the same time desktop screen real estate became a non-issue for everyone (a 32" monitor at 1600x1200 used to be a luxury, now it's mundane). Now no one knows if there is anything "below the fold" without initiating a scroll action, which just encourages people to further only focus on the above the fold content.

Interestingly the response to that was sites adding horizontal "progress bars" across the top of the viewport to indicate how much you had read. And with application and website control of the styling and operation of these standard widgets, everyone is slightly different, which increases time to become familiar.

It's been a race to the bottom, in the name of (the subjective at best) "clean design".

Fr0styMatt88 1 day ago | parent

I feel like wide screens and ultra-wide screens are massively under-utilised in UX design and there’s a lot of untapped potential there.

TimTheTinker 1 day ago | parent

A lack of information density... I felt like I could glean more from the above-the-fold Yahoo.com site in 2001 than any site today.

Note Japan has not embraced the so-called "clean" UI design aesthetic. Check out any Japanese website and it looks like US web sites in 1999, but even more so. I wouldn't mind me some of that.

Lumich 1 day ago | parent

« This was then translated to desktop apps at the same time desktop screen real estate became a non-issue for everyone »

Exactly. I remember opening a Metro/TIFKAM app for the first time on my new Windows 8 connected to my new 27" QHD monitor, and then staring in bewilderment as it went fullscreen and 95 % of the screen was just monochrome with nothing on it at all.

Wtf were they thinking? That I would enjoy vanilla sauce on my roastbeef because they weren't serving strawberries yet?

Still puzzling to me how such a multi-billion $ company can fuck up so hard.

marginalia_nu 1 day ago | parent

Skeumorphism isn't necessary for consistency in user interfaces, but it generally ensures a level of consistency that is honestly hard in modern interface design.

encom 1 day ago | parent

>Lets find the scrollbar

Related: Whoever decided to allow to websites style browser scroll bars, should have their teeth kicked in.

the-dude 20 hours ago | parent

Dude, this is not 'Nam.

I don't want to read this on HN : flagged.

pjmlp 1 day ago | parent

On Windows it is easy, unless an application somehow hooks into the workflow, it always goes into the order of what was used last.

thesuitonym 1 day ago | parent

Skeuomorphism isn't the only thing we've lost, and really it's the least important. We're talking smaller ideas, like widgets that aren't just black text on a white background (or if you like dark mode, white text on a grey background), visible scrollbars, menus.

AlienRobot 1 day ago | parent

That has nothing to do with discoverability. Discoverability isn't about "guessing" it's about being able to see it.

Discoverability in CLI is --help. But you can't discover you have to use --help. So CLI is always fundamentally worse than GUI.

robotresearcher 1 day ago | parent

You also have to just know what program to invoke with the —help arg.

Good luck guessing ‘grep’ from first principles.

topaz0 1 day ago | parent

Man -k is often good for this

topaz0 1 day ago | parent

It helps that for most cli tools, any incorrect usage will show the usage text, including --help

Telaneo 1 day ago | parent

If --help even lists everything. man [whatever] might contain more options. And both may leave out critical information.

xigoi 1 day ago | parent

> Discoverability in CLI is --help.

Unless it’s one of those programs that are like “unrecognized option --help, use -h to see help”.

andy81 1 day ago | parent

I love knowing that a "Get-Foo" function in a library I've never before isn't going to have side-effects (unless malicious).

Conventions are great for UX.

https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/powershell/scripting/devel...

Mikhail_Edoshin 1 day ago | parent

An interesting study, will try to find it, thanks. I've been thinking about "naming things" and it seems the common idea of "good naming" is pretty superficial. I myself would point to MOV in assembly, which is actually COPY, but this never was an issue.

What actually matters is that:

- Names express not only differences, but also similarities.

- Names cannot be totally random; they must have certain pre-baked relations vaguely similar to their relations in the model. But they do not need to be too good. Invented or repurposed names in moderations are perfectly fine.

- The most important thing in naming is the overall consistency. But when the system changes you need more names and the consistency suffers. After a few rounds it gets too bad and you need to redo the whole system. This us why naming is hard.

- Certain physical properties matter, such as equal length.

- Names are very similar to pictograms or hieroglyphs.

pbhjpbhj 1 day ago | parent

>command names should be changed to something more meaningful than cat, sed, grep etc.

    cat - con-cat-enates
    sed - is a stream editor
    grep - global regex print
Not sure you picked the best examples. But trying to think of examples where the name is not related to the function ... ag, unless you're the sort of person to use ag, has an obscure name.

throwaway652563 1 day ago | parent

cat is just catenate.

xigoi 1 day ago | parent

> But trying to think of examples where the name is not related to the function

Git?

BirAdam 1 day ago | parent

Nope. Throw a Southern US accent on "get"

"I needda git it from the repo"

red_admiral 1 day ago | parent

My experience is that 'ls' and the like are fine once you've used them a few times. 'list-files' would just be more typing, and even with tab completion there's probably other things to list so muscle memory would end up at [l] [tab] [f] [tab] or something like that.

The one that constantly trips me up is 'which' vs 'where' but that's for a different reason.

('Get-ChildItem' is an abomination.)

baud147258 21 hours ago | parent

At least dir is aliased to Get-ChildItem nowadays, so it's less typing

red_admiral 1 hour ago | parent

As well as 'ls'.

roughly 1 day ago | parent

Re: too far - it’s interesting, because there’s two reasons skeumorphism “works” - one is because it provides visual cues for how a virtual object will behave when acted upon, which lets our brain build a quick intuitive understanding of how to interact with a foreign object that draws on all our experience outside the computer, and two is because the visual mimicry of the physical object gives our brains immediate cues to understand what it’s seeing and build that interaction model.

This one absolutely over indexes on that second principle, to a borderline cartoonish degree, but I expect the reason it’s resonating so hard is exactly what you’re indicating, that in the industry’s desire to be able to move on from the tether to the shapes of physical objects, they discarded that first principle entirely, instead of figuring out how to maintain the visual cues to form and operation in a new language.

(Here’s where I throw away all that credibility I just got from the prior two paragraphs: I actually think Liquid Glass is getting closer to a “skeumorphism without skeumorphism” than anything else I’ve seen out there.)

pkulak 1 day ago | parent

> I don't know why anybody would.

Well, there's really two things going on here: consumer vs professional. Does an electrician need to "discover" the modes on her multimeter? Naw. Do I need to discover where the wiper controls are on the car I just rented? Absolutely! But I'm not a huge fan of UI fluff that helps me discover things on my work machine.

Loquebantur 1 day ago | parent

The idea of "one size fits all" was never true.

Weirdly, there is some kind of power play happening with OS UI: "MBA finally in position of influence wants to force their taste on everybody" appears to be a thing.

Uncle_Brumpus 1 day ago | parent

Your rental car comment reminds me of the time I looked like an idiot trying to open the fuel door on a rented Kia K5 for almost 20 minutes. I don't have a smartphone and didn't have my laptop so had no way to look anything up. Ended up finding this video on the gas station employee's phone (she came out to see if everything was okay. It was not okay.) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_e7lZmbjtNo

If you have to release a tutorial video to open your fuel filler door, and that video includes the one easy piece of user interface to do the thing getting thanos-snapped out of existence, I think you did something wrong.

The cause of my problem was I opened the driver's door before turning off the car. The rental didn't have push-to-start like my personal vehicle, and I don't have "turn and remove key" on the mind when exiting a vehicle. Even locking and unlocking the door didn't unlock the fuel door, I had to turn the car back on, lock the doors, turn the car off, then unlock the doors. Why is opening the fuel door so complicated? There doesn't seem to be any way to do it mechanically, so good luck when the solenoid dies.

Fr0styMatt88 1 day ago | parent

Hahahaha the first time I tried to get into a Tesla and couldn’t figure out how to open the doors from the outside.

bombela 1 day ago | parent

The fact that it requires a very specific sequence of state change to unlock is the issue.

Plenty of cars have automatic fuel door locks that work seamlessly.

IslandRebel 1 day ago | parent

I have a key, and I then turn the cap.

https://embertonimperial.com/products/stc4072-locking-fuel-f...

hobo123 1 day ago | parent

Lol, that was me when I had a rented Toyota. I thought the lever was for the engine hood or something, so I didn't even try it.

necovek 1 day ago | parent

All the multimeters I've seen had pretty bog standard markings for AC and DC resistance, voltage and current. While not an electrician myself, I think one would be pretty annoyed if a "designer" invented new graphics for alternating current or resistance. They might even gotten hurt or damaged some equipment.

So when consistent UX is applied, both a professional and amateur alike can learn and trust that what they learned carries over.

VCFundedGenYer 1 day ago | parent

> Discoverability? Who needs it?

Most "flat" designed modern apps fail miserably at discovery. Most hide things in hamburger menus or require weird random swipes in odd directions with zero visual indicators.

thwarted 1 day ago | parent

I got bit by this recently. Brave on android has no "forward button in the app menu, it only has back. Chrome has both forward and back in the menu. Both browsers support swiping from the right side to go forward in the history stack (although this seems to be overloaded with switching tabs in a tab group), which I discovered by accident. What's odd about this though is that the device has a global back button that is also used for backward history navigation, but that's been duplicated in brave with an additional back action in the menu, but the forward history navigation is entirely hidden and has only one way to invoke it: via swiping.

prmph 1 day ago | parent

Modern design is not synonymous to dis-empowering design.

FWIW I love modern design, and I hate all these too clever skeuomorphs. Modern design is honest to the digital medium. I find its beauty lies, not in the quirky ways it tries to mimic real textures and objects, but by how it provides usable controls and information by applying basic design elements like spacing, alignment, color, typography, discovery, layered info density, etc. well.

None of these requires skeuomorphs. It is like the difference between thinking a website is visually impressive and stunning because it uses a nice background image. That would not impress me. What would impress me are stuff like: does it have an effective information architecture, as reflected in it main menu and general link structure? Does it use a tasteful and usable color scheme? Does it have an interesting and still usable visual grouping? Etc.

hotsauceror 1 day ago | parent

I fully agree with this take. I don't think of a monitor / desktop as a tool that I interact with like I would a hammer; there is nothing intuitive about "open this high-definition representation of a day planner by clicking a button with your thumb on this little round plastic box somewhere else." I simply do not understand the appeal of skeumorphism, frankly I think these things look tacky but that is just my preference.

My interactions are with content, generally as strings of text but often as picture/video/audio. I prefer that my 'desktop' apply the principles you've mentioned, to the problem of tastefully and comfortably arranging, displaying, and manipulating that content, and little else. Some types of controls that lean skeuomorphic, like sliders or switches, may be useful and even intuitive in that endeavor; others, like an analog knob or dial, aren't. If I want to watch a video, display it in a minimal, tasteful frame; I do not need a representation of an old 1970s wooden TV or something.

creaturemachine 1 day ago | parent

Way too far. I don't want my desktop to look like a puzzle straight out of Myst, or a reinvention of Bob.

rerdavies 1 day ago | parent

In fairness, this is Myst not Bob.

roarcher 1 day ago | parent

Do all those toggle switches and dials and sliders actually help discovery for people who grew up with iPads? Maybe their function is only obvious to us dinosaurs.

OroPla 1 day ago | parent

> Discoverability? Who needs it?

It wouldn't be so important if things didn't change so much over the years. The CLI has stayed fairly consistent over the past 40 or so years. Can't say the same about GUI, though.

I wouldn't have to rediscover all functionality if designers didn't shuffle things around for no reason. Though, that's mostly a Windows thing, which I have to use for work.

manoDev 1 day ago | parent

These lessons made sense for users born before personal computers, but it's debatable if these lessons are transferable to so called "digital native" users.

Fr0styMatt88 1 day ago | parent

Ha I feel like modern interior design and apartment design does exactly the same thing these days. Everything looks the same kind of bland.

sleepybrett 1 day ago | parent

I think it depends on audience. I think there is a place for the 'Microsoft Bob' s of the world. My 90+ year old grandma would probably use a computer if we sanded down all the hard edges and kept her in a box (computationally speaking). Hell my 70+ year old mother, even though she's had a computer for 35ish years prefers her ipad for just that reason (simpler than her hand-me-down macbooks i keep her supplied with).

GuB-42 1 day ago | parent

The UX disaster is not just about looking "clean" and "sleek". It is all about mobile. The choice between bland colored boxes, skeuomorphism and other styles is just looks, it doesn't change the fundamentals.

Here is the problem: smartphones have a small screens and are operated using fat fingers, so you need big buttons and you don't have much space, so you are very limited in the amount of stuff you can put on screen. It also means there is a lot of hidden stuff.

Now that having a mobile app, or a mobile optimized website is often a requirement, the desktop app usually follows the mobile conventions, which is not great, but better than doing it the other way. Having two entirely different apps to make the best use of the platform is possible, but it is expensive, and you want to maintain some level of consistency, so that users switching between desktop and mobile won't be lost. You probably want to maintain branding too.

To me, it is not that designers don't know how to do good UX like they did in the 90s/00s, it is that there are contradictory requirements and they have to make compromises.

netrap 1 day ago | parent

Microsoft BOB!

serf 23 hours ago | parent

a single color QT/mosaic interface is the definition of bland jurassic park UI and it's refreshing to use every after getting stuck dealing with modern machines and interfaces.

javier2 1 day ago | parent

e16/e17 was a lot of fun, and it was fast.

Beijinger 1 day ago | parent

e17 (Moksha) IS still fun!

https://www.bodhilinux.com/moksha-desktop/

Beijinger 1 day ago | parent

What do you mean 20 years ago? I still use enlightenment today (Moksha Desktop)

WD-42 1 day ago | parent

If the 23oz Of Glass or Orange Juice themes are usable I’ll switch right now

lelanthran 1 day ago | parent

> What do you mean 20 years ago? I still use enlightenment today (Moksha Desktop)

Enlightenment today (https://www.enlightenment.org/_media/aa/shot-2021-12-13_17-4...) looks nowhere nearly as cool as it used to:

https://imgur.com/enlightenment-are-we-posting-throwbacks-de...

http://robert.thegeakes.co.uk/images/elive.jpg

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:E17_screenshot.jpg

https://www.reddit.com/r/unixporn/comments/fq4y3c/e17_found_...

jacobgkau 1 day ago | parent

Is it just a default theme difference, or is the current version actually less themable?

Also, the person you replied to mentioned Moksha; that's a fork of Enlightenment 17 (which is what at least two of your cool-looking example screenshots appear to be from).

mahboi 1 day ago | parent

The one today doesn't look skeuomorphic at all

pkulak 1 day ago | parent

As someone who runs a super-boring, stock tiler with zero decoration or bling; couldn't agree more. It's this kind of thing that gets new users interested in Linux. _I_ started using Linux because I saw some video of wobbly windows, and desktops on a giant rotating cube.

theraido 1 day ago | parent

It's probably not the same one, but I suddenly had Project Looking Glass flashbacks

ibizaman 1 day ago | parent

Me too! I was drawn to trying out Ubuntu from seeing all the cool Compiz effects.

imp0cat 1 day ago | parent

I still run the Burn My Windows Gnome extension on all my desktops with a short "TV Effect" activated when a windows closes. It's just perfect!

https://github.com/schneegans/burn-my-windows

creaturemachine 1 day ago | parent

That was Compiz iirc. I remember turning it on for a laugh.

Symbiote 1 day ago | parent

KDE 6, at least as the latest Kubuntu has it configured, has the wobble back by default.

It hasn't annoyed me enough to disable it just yet, but it's only been a week.

0xbadcafebee 1 day ago | parent

I would like a Linux desktop that doesn't suck first, then they can make it pretty. Every Linux desktop I've used in the past decade is either so minimal it's barely usable, or so feature-filled it takes up gigs of ram, or in the middle with broken clunky features (where I am now with LXQt). And the worst thing is, it's all the same goddamn thing as what we had 20 years ago, but somehow keeps getting rewritten to be slower and suckier.

TFNA 1 day ago | parent

I installed Debian with KDE on a couple of non-techy relatives' mid-range laptops around Covid, and in spite of KDE being notorious for its abundance of features, neither of those relatives have ever complained about slowness or lag. That era seems far in the past now.

dv35z 1 day ago | parent

Give Mint Debian a try - I've been very happy with it.

https://linuxmint.com/download_lmde.php

mahboi 1 day ago | parent

Kinda same, I want there to be something reasonable that 99% of people can agree on. It shouldn't be that hard. Things seemed fine back with Gnome2, then, everything changed when the

hobo123 1 day ago | parent

Huh? Mate (formerly known as Gnome 2) is pretty functional and almost as lightweight as Xfce.

Cinnamon (comes with Linux Mint) is a modern refresh that's very functional and not at all heavy or slow.

If you don't want a desktop, I guess there are many good WMs to choose from.

Gualdrapo 1 day ago | parent

Call me insane but I still think xfce and Enlightenment should do a fusion become one project. Get rid of the GNOME shenanigans on GTK and rewrite all xfce apps and stuff in the e libraries.

BirAdam 1 day ago | parent

EFL is super lightweight, but it also offers more than does GTK. It'd be a complex rewrite.

andai 1 day ago | parent

>if you like bland, that should be an option too

That's the main thing we lost, isn't it? Options. I remember playing with so many different themes back in the day.

haolez 1 day ago | parent

I feel that a desktop like this would just occupy parts of my cognition for no good reason. Not sure.

Retr0id 1 day ago | parent

> the kind iOS 6 had

> The room is ray-traced

imho, part of the charm of iOS6 was that everything was baked into native-resolution textures.

ramijames 1 day ago | parent

I feel like that was simply a limitation of the hardware at the time. Given modern hardware, I'm willing to bet that people of the 2000s would have made wild stuff.

vollbrecht 1 day ago | parent

Totally. Using Windows Vista Ultimate just for using Windows DreamScene ( e.g playing a video as a desktop background). Totally dumb, totally destroyed performance, totally cool :D

jacknews 1 day ago | parent

How come the 'documents' are floating above the wood surface creating such deep drop shadows?

KerrAvon 1 day ago | parent

okay, now use this for a month and report back

I don't hate skeuomorphic design but come on man

netsharc 1 day ago | parent

This is so terribly and unthinkingly done. What calculator looks like a paper notebook in real life? If you want to list apps, what's the appropriate metaphor? The designer thought "Oh, let's make it a list on paper in a notebook...". Why not e.g a toolchest with all the tools available to represent all the programs you have installed? (If you ask me to brainstorm an idea)

shaolinspirit 1 day ago | parent

fascinating, I recently was also exploring various skeuomorphic design pattern in Flutter and now this!

ragazzina 1 day ago | parent

> Windows are sheets of paper on a walnut desk.

The calculator is a sheet of paper..

Beijinger 1 day ago | parent

memory 4 GB (DEsk itself 200-450 MB)

This makes it interesting. I may try it out. Moksha uses 200 MB to 300 MB of RAM

DonHopkins 1 day ago | parent

In Brett Victor's 2011 essay, "A Brief Rant on the Future of Interaction Design", he laid out the foundation for his critique of skeuomorphic design. He believes hands are our future.

https://worrydream.com/ABriefRantOnTheFutureOfInteractionDes...

On the visual pretense: "Pictures Under Glass sacrifice all the tactile richness of working with our hands, offering instead a hokey visual facade."

On touchscreens mimicking real objects without haptics: "Pictures Under Glass is an interaction paradigm of permanent numbness. It's a Novocaine drip to the wrist. It denies our hands what they do best."

On why this design path is short-sighted: "To me, claiming that Pictures Under Glass is the future of interaction is like claiming that black-and-white is the future of photography. It's obviously a transitional technology. And the sooner we transition, the better."

Arubis 1 day ago | parent

I can feel my shoulders unlocking looking at the screenshots.

lelanthran 1 day ago | parent

This is pretty cool! I'd use this, once out of beta.

(Bonus points for not throwing AI-tells at everyone in the README - much appreciated).

mrsssnake 1 day ago | parent

Skeuomorphic design was a solution to teaching the customer how to use the digital product, but I wish we have more of its side effects like shadows, icons that pop and other things that are pleasant for the eye and depth.

I don't know if it's just because it was better or am I just tired of the current white (like #FFFFFF white) backgrounds with everything flat and not connected. I would like my browser tabs to be in the shape of a physical tab in notebooks.

pid0x17 1 day ago | parent

It feels like UI design froze somewhere in the mid-2010s. There are some changes here and there, but it all looks similar and very bland.

I don't know if this is accurate, but I blame Windows 8 and, especially, Windows 10 for popularizing this extremely bland and boring design.

treetalker 1 day ago | parent

> DEsk is Desktop Environment and desk in one word

They dropped the ball:

DESk would have been Desktop Environment, desk, and Skeumorphic in one word.

reedlaw 1 day ago | parent

Or go full acronym with Kit for the K as in "Developer Kit".

lpghatguy 1 day ago | parent

The README being so full of AI prose is super grating.

wodenokoto 1 day ago | parent

It seems like the developer is Japanese (the dev log is in Japanese according to the readme) so for once I am willing to believe this is a case of “the dev is not a native speaker” - but yes, I wondered several times reading the readme if this whole thing is vibe coded

usagisushi 1 day ago | parent

Actually, his Japanese is pretty strange too. As a native speaker, it doesn't even feel like Japanese-Claudish. It feels more like it was translated from some other language, or maybe he just didn't bother reviewing the Haiku 3 output at all.

wodenokoto 1 day ago | parent

Thanks for checking. The plot thickens.

mrsssnake 1 day ago | parent

The thing I hate with vibed apps the most is zero seconds spend on how things around what is being build are already structured and what problems was already solved, just focusing on shiny result.

`sudo sh scripts/install_debian.sh`, a 583 lines long script, basically now a whole software just to handle the installation of this project on one distribution, seriously? If we vibecode already, just do the normal packaging.

V__ 1 day ago | parent

I can imagine this being really helpful for beginners and kids. It's hard to grok what windows and tabs are etc. without any context.

diegolas 1 day ago | parent

god please no

ilaksh 1 day ago | parent

I think AR/XR glasses are going to start to become popular in the next couple of years and I think some mixed reality shells will have more physical/3d interfaces.

tillmannhgl 1 day ago | parent

Sweet

hotelsacher 1 day ago | parent

That control panel looks fantastic! Too bad I don't wayland. Last I checked, Mathematica doesn't like it.

hliyan 1 day ago | parent

This adds to a belief that I have that UI design undergoes cycles like fashion, just that we haven't yet seen a complete cycle.

mcv 1 day ago | parent

This looks like peak skeuomorphism. I like it, but ray-tracing the desktop sounds like overkill.

itomato 1 day ago | parent

I'd be into something as useful as Quartz Composer was for Desktop Widgets, but not a full skeuomorphic desktop.

Indigo Magic or CDE is as close as I'd want to go with that concept.

2004 was a long time ago, and I suppose what is old can be new (again).

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQQPTtdzBig

nirav72 1 day ago | parent

I thought we were done with the skeuomorphism craze back in the late 00s. (Thanks Apple). Is the trend coming back?

AbraKdabra 1 day ago | parent

> Is the trend coming back?

Hopefully no.

dijit 1 day ago | parent

Hopefully yes.

iPhone 4s with native resolution textures felt truly magical.

not this flat on flat, grey and text as buttons shite that has pervaded UI for the last decade+

kogasa240p 1 day ago | parent

Very interesting concept but I doubt it's stable due to the amount of slopped code and I don't like that it requires a hodgepoge of libraries from different DEs.

ortusdux 1 day ago | parent

Please tell me it has coffee ring stains and spiral lined notebooks.

tavavex 1 day ago | parent

I'm typically not a big proponent of skeuomorphism, but it's nice to have actual variety of experimental options, a bit like the crazy things people did with UIs back in the old days.

luqtas 1 day ago | parent

HN crowd be like: THANKS GOD APPLE WILL NEVER OPEN-SOURCE THE DE SO WE CAN'T HAVE THEMES FOR INDIVIDUALS WHO WANTS THEM

ffin 1 day ago | parent

themes are actually possible on macos

https://github.com/CoreBedtime/playground

einpoklum 1 day ago | parent

I am skeptical that a transition from X to Wayland is actually merited.

As for the post / the repo itself, this analysis:

https://www.salahadawi.com/hacker-news-ai-detector/50103338

suggests it is LLM-generated. Not sure what to make of it.

tenacious_tuna 1 day ago | parent

This is a really enjoyable take, pushing the feeling of what one does on a computer towards actually being at a desk and having to reach for various functions. I feel like that would enable spatial memory to do some cool things.

I miss the 90s chunkiness of switches, buttons, hardware: being able to hear the computer "think" (HDD seeks), the hum of a CRT. Modern machinery feels so insubstantial, emphasizing clean glass and tidy machined chassis. (chassies?)

I have this persistent daydream about a computer setup that feels like the Nostromo flight deck from Alien. I almost want to feel like I'm sitting _inside_ a computer when I'm at my desk, surrounded by powerful feeling electronics with substantial switches and such. Of course there's plenty of inconvenience there too, but something about it appeals to me.

SpaceL10n 1 day ago | parent

Singular and plural chassis are spelled the same, but that doesn't make it right! I'm more inclined to spell it chassises personally.

dijit 1 day ago | parent

Chassis'

notpushkin 1 day ago | parent

Chasses :-)

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/-sis

pinho 1 day ago | parent

Spelled the same, but pronounced differently: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/chassis

rerdavies 1 day ago | parent

Replace language with an actually sensible one, and press any key to continue!

If nothing else, that is a truly sadistic trivia question. I wonder if there are any other words in the English language whose plural form is spelled the same, but pronounced differently.

swiftcoder 1 day ago | parent

I think all the others that do this are loanwords from French? We keep the silent s at the end in the singular, and make it audible in the plural - faux pas, corps, précis, etc.

There are a bunch of other heteronyms, but I can't think of others that differ specifically in the plural

rerdavies 1 day ago | parent

Excellent! And even stranger. In French, the singular and plural forms have the same pronunciation! Damned Rosbif can't do ANYTHING right. lol.

The Artificial General Intelligence (Claude) gives a few more examples (but only after having been prompted with your examples):

- Rendezvous, hors d'eouvre, patois, chamois, bourgeois, glacis, fracas (dialect dependent), debris (rare), pince nez (dialect dependent).

mzi 1 day ago | parent

Corps. And you do have past and present of reading spelled the same and pronounced differently.

frankvdwaal 1 day ago | parent

If you want to take the weirdness a step further, just look at the plural for "woman". When you write "women" you only change the second vowel, but when you pronounce that same word you only change the first.

somat 1 day ago | parent

It is a french word and it is inherently plural, sort of like pants, by my best guess, having only looked it up just now, singuler chassis would be a case.

So chassis, the thing full of parts, case, same thing but without the parts?

chaps 1 day ago | parent

Chassipodes

rerdavies 1 day ago | parent

Chassae.

drivingmenuts 1 day ago | parent

Buggerall.

somat 1 day ago | parent

It's inherently plural, can't have just one. sort of like pants I guess. It is a container of parts.

embedding-shape 1 day ago | parent

> It's inherently plural

> It is a container

Did you mean "It is containers"? Or is it actually possible to have a singular container of parts?

somat 23 hours ago | parent

Based on the etymology, I suspect the singular of chassis is case. Nobody uses it like that. But you would perhaps use chassis when it is full of parts or as an item that could be full of parts and case when empty or the parts don't matter.

Surprisingly enough, despite nobody using it like this, it works well, except for cars, where the singular form would be frame(car case just does not work), which does not share the same root and as such is a bit disappointing.

And what is also disapointing, despite the word already being plural(a french spelling of latin pluralization rules for case, use the latin soft c for case and add an i to pluralize, under french rules "is", the s is silent), When there are several chassis, we use the english pluralization rules and add an s. And because there is already an s we just add an s sound.

sellmesoap 1 day ago | parent

We just need to add more sound effects tied to system monitor probes to get those HDD noises back, kinda like how electric cars have that parking lot noise to make sure pedestrians are aware of them in lieu of an engine banging away! Being inside the computer like being at a pipe organ console, or surrounded by screens like a hacker in a dystopian hovercraft!

brody_hamer 1 day ago | parent

My desktop is wired up using Ethernet over powerline (was easier than running a cable) and it creates some noise through my desktop speakers.

The issue is easily fixed with better grounding, but I’ve found that I prefer the noise. I can hear my network traffic, and I’ve come to use it as mental input. (“Op, I can hear that my script has reached the write-to-s3 step”)

parpfish 1 day ago | parent

a couple weeks ago i was lamenting the lack of hard-drive noises to know when my computer was "thinking", and came across this fun little app:

https://disknoice-655ee8.gitlab.io/

it's got the right noises and i believe that they are synced up with real disk usage, but it doesn't quite feel the same because i think disk usage patterns have changed over the last 20-some years.

anajimi 1 day ago | parent

Hey you may like this project: https://github.com/AdoPi/wlgblock

yndoendo 1 day ago | parent

You want your key input controls to be based off of the book _The Secret Doctrine_ by Helena Blavatsky? [0]

[0] https://www.jwz.org/blog/2014/12/alien-1970s-city-futura-hel...

dmbche 1 day ago | parent

Is that the new rick roll? What's up?

yndoendo 1 day ago | parent

That is strange.

The URL only works properly with Firefox in Private mode or with LibreWolf.

Guess the person that runs the community does not like HN.

dmbche 1 day ago | parent

Oh wow ! What a weird thing to stumble upon. First time it happens to me, kudos to them.

Have a good one!

Edit0: and cool link thanks!

adiM 1 day ago | parent

Wow! There would come a time when kids on hacker news will not recognize jwz!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jamie_Zawinski

yndoendo 1 day ago | parent

Thanks for that. I can understand his disdain. Too many on here worship wealth and bad actors like Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg, and Tim Sweeney who only care to propel their own wealth. There is a void of humanity and humility in such people.

Real intelligence must incorporate empathy. Lacking empathy means people lack real intelligence.

I respect people like Jamie Zawinski and Steve Wozniak. It is not about the wealth it about making a good product and solution. That is real value.

Also explains how he has the know it all to setup his site and fingerprint people logged into HN.

embedding-shape 1 day ago | parent

> Also explains how he has the know it all to setup his site and fingerprint people logged into HN.

    if $referrer.contains('news.ycombinator.com') { displayHairyEgg() }
Think most web developers who learned web development before LLMs would be able to do the same :)

broken-kebab 1 day ago | parent

Yes, that goldless monk Woz. Sure thing he never thought about propelling his own wealth while reaching 120 mln

yndoendo 23 hours ago | parent

There is a great deal difference between billions and millions. People have a hard time understanding powers of 10.

There is also giving away your wealth to others versus consolidating it and hording it like a dragon ....

But you know ... too many people look up to inhuman individuals like Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg, and Tim Sweeney. Those that do are are detrimental to a civilized world.

You can create wealth by creating a good product that does not exploit the users nor those that assisted you on the creation and delivery. This is were our current large organizations fail to understand.

Exploit, exploit, to support that Friedman doctrine is the go to now. This were the three listed above support.

adjejmxbdjdn 21 hours ago | parent

That’s unfair to Milton Friedman who, unlike the America. right wing retelling of his economics, would likely be aghast at the modern levels of inequality and concentration of power.

He did support what was basically progressive taxation, but suggested structuring it as a negative tax, where instead of increasing tax rates with income, you had a flat tax rate with minimal deductions, but you imposed a negative tax as you went down the income ladder.

broken-kebab 21 hours ago | parent

You're trying to dress fanboyist attitude as some sort of moral stance.

Your statement was about people who "propel their wealth" vs those who somehow don't. With this in mind there's no difference between 10 mln and 10 bln - neither would happen for a person who doesn't want it to happen. "Good product" is irrelevant to moral estimation as well cause bad people can make good products, and vice versa. Finally, Starlink as an example is probably less exploitative compared to Apple's consistent walled-garden strategy. It doesn't tell us anything about Musk's morality, but rather clearly shows your logic as inconsistent.

netsharc 23 hours ago | parent

Silicon Valley/tech used to be hippies, but the money-hungry noticed it's somewhere to make money, and swarmed to it.

Look at Cliff Stoll, for example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=656058JxTM0

And no wonder those "money!" people hang out in a forum made by a venture capital company...

I wrote this comment the other day, it got flagged to death:

> As someone who downloaded, over 28.8K modem, a version of the Jargon File (1) as a plain text file (2) to read during a school vacation, in the "good old days" of my imagination Silicon Valley was a lot cooler for hackers. But people noticed it was a place to make money, and all the money-hungry MBAs showed up, and now the whole industry has a stench to it..

(1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jargon_File (2) https://jargon-file.org/archive/jargon-4.4.7.dos.txt

trombuance 1 day ago | parent

How come? I never use private mode and assumed it simply clears cookies and history after the session ends. Is there more to it?

embedding-shape 1 day ago | parent

Every time you click on a link, your browser helpfully tells the website that the link goes to, where you come from.

Try clicking this link and see what it says :) https://www.whatismybrowser.com/detect/what-is-my-referrer/

skilning 1 day ago | parent

It's a little more complicated than that. Even pasting the link into a new window (so no referrer) shows the image, at least after visiting the site for the first time.

embedding-shape 22 hours ago | parent

> It's a little more complicated than that

Keyword being "a little". It's a cookie set on previous visit.

    $ document.cookie
    > HN=1
Delete the cookie, then open new tab, copy-paste the link and it works just fine. It's not rocket science, at least it didn't used to be :)

hobo123 1 day ago | parent

Wow, didn't know jwz is wearing his head up his ass now. Sad way to treat your readers by assuming that everyone who reads certain websites is a certain kind of person?

serf 23 hours ago | parent

"Whoever screwed up my egg should get the sack!"

at least thee 'hairy egg' one made me laugh; the alternate i've seen lately is a plea to avoid mentioning that they're furry if you're from HN using the HN referrer; that one is a bit more groan-inducing than the full page anti-capitalism nut scree.

reaperducer 1 day ago | parent

pushing the feeling of what one does on a computer towards actually being at a desk and having to reach for various functions

I love this. And it also reminds me of Magic Desk for the Commodore 64.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magic_Desk

I now have a reason to put Linux on my old Intel Mac.

qurren 1 day ago | parent

This gives me Microsoft Bob vibes

herdymerzbow 1 day ago | parent

"I miss the 90s chunkiness of switches, buttons, hardware: being able to hear the computer "think" (HDD seeks), the hum of a CRT. Modern machinery feels so insubstantial, emphasizing clean glass and tidy machined chassis. (chassies?)"

That's one of the appeals of mechanical keyboards for me. It's primarily the visual and aural aesthetic (thock thock thock....or clack clack clack) but married to the silent billion or so switches frantically turning on or off on the PC next to me, it kind of gives me the tactile feedback that I want from the process.

mrmlz 1 day ago | parent

Hey the clunkiness, the slow thinking, the hardware buzz (fans) and the feeling that your computer is a living being (an evil one) is well alive in my worklaptop.

Fucking piece of shit.

skilning 1 day ago | parent

> tidy machined chassis. (chassies?)

I think you mean "chassissessieses"? :)

tamimio 1 day ago | parent

Coupled with steam frame headset this might be great experience.

flowerlad 1 day ago | parent

This project highlights why designers hate skeuomorphism. Skeuomorphism looks tacky unless done very very well. Skeuomorphic design under Steve Jobs looked very good. This doesn't come close.

Kiln6125 1 day ago | parent

Personally I don't super care if a designer thinks I'm being tacky if its making my day to day more fun.

chrisguilbeau 1 day ago | parent

I always think about video game UI's when I read the skeuomorphic design arugments. I suspect video games use them, at the very least, because they are delightful and fun; which, in my opinion, is a good reason to do something anywhere.

I will say that a long time ago I installed enlightenment and after about 10 minutes the burning windows felt like they were getting in the way, so I guess, like everything, there should be balance.

TomJansen 1 day ago | parent

Fun, makes me think of Bumptop :)

aintnoprophet 1 day ago | parent

Yes. I hope it lasts longer.

mahboi 1 day ago | parent

Wow, I remember having this on my Mac as a kid

kerm1t_ 1 day ago | parent

nice! would be cool to customize to different era's of office life ... or even a creative version, e.g. Picasso's desktop

jhoechtl 1 day ago | parent

BeOS of 2026?

elxr 1 day ago | parent

Love skeuomorphism. This just gave me a reminder to build a paper-like calendar app now, with pencil markings showing events.

I definitely don't want a skeuomorphic desktop, but little web-apps, text editors, chat apps? I say we need a lot more of this type of design there, especially with how good modern CSS is at this kind of thing.

inamberclad 1 day ago | parent

Sorry, that doesn't look like a walnut desk. That looks like stained pine wood.

tombert 1 day ago | parent

I stand by that OS X Maverick was the most beautiful of all the macOS releases.

Actually that OS in general is what convinced me to buy a mac in like 2014; it felt like nearly every criticism I had with macOS at the time had been addressed. I miss those days.

ptaffs 1 day ago | parent

I thought Maverick reduced the skeuomorphism, I was glad to see it removed. Apple had got to a point where shadows and reflections weren't consistent between icons and windows and the Dock. Briefly, Microsoft lead good design with Metro and the flat, minimal background noise.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metro_(design_language)

https://www.macworld.com/article/222218/get-to-know-os-x-mav...

tombert 1 day ago | parent

I felt like Mavericks had just the right amount of skeuomorphism. Not enough to be annoying but just enough to be aesthetic.

I was never a fan of the Metro flat design that took over, though admittedly my desktop now is a purposefully unsexy Sway desktop that is completely flat and I do like that.

mahboi 1 day ago | parent

Agreed, but I also don't really care as long as it's usable. Some flat design made things harder to see/read, but by Sequoia, they'd figured out how much depth needed to be added. Tahoe / Liquid Glass is whatever, I have high-contrast mode which nullifies it.

AbraKdabra 1 day ago | parent

Please no, seriously, fuck skeumorphism. There's a reason everybody stopped using it.

mahboi 1 day ago | parent

Apple went back to it

andai 1 day ago | parent

This warms my heart.

I was just thinking about this the other week, when I bought an old iPhone, from the skeumorphic era, for nostalgic purposes. I've wanted one for years -- I only had the newer ones that were flat.

I always thought, nah, I'm just seeing thru rose tinted glasses, surely it wasn't that cool, I'm gonna be disappointed...

Well, I finally got one, and oh boy. It's even better than I imagined. There's just so much love and care put into the designs. We really lost something special.

(p.s. if you get a really old iPhone, don't reset the device. It's impossible to activate them now, found out the hard way.)

mahboi 1 day ago | parent

Every time some permanent downgrade was made to iPhones, everyone said you're afraid of change / it's nostalgia / you'll get used to it. Nope. iPhone 5S (or SE?) running iOS 6 is still the best combo ever. iOS 7 ruined the design, and it never fully recovered. BT is still not a replacement for headphone jack. The swipe gestures get mis-inputted all the time. Liquid Glass actually looked nice, but it introduced Android-level lag and glitches, like 1/3 of the time my camera doesn't load.

Biggest thing though, they broke the keyboard. Thought I was losing my mind after years of using a 6, 6S, 12 mini and still mistyping horribly. Then I picked up my iPhone 5 that hadn't been touched in years since ATT banned it, so there's no way I'm used to it... Instantly typed way faster with 0 mistakes. I'm not the only one, there must be some Ba Sing Se type of denial going on at Apple with the keyboard.

If it's so bad, why am I even using it? I'm kinda not. I use my laptop whenever possible now. I call more often than texting on my phone, and on speakerphone instead of earbuds. It didn't get fixed, just had to adapt. And all of this is practicality, not even touching how special the old iPhone felt.

Doohickey-d 1 day ago | parent

> It's impossible to activate them now

There's easy jailbreak options to bypass the activation for those and have a functional device, nowdays.

rootedbox 1 day ago | parent

Do you want your desktop to feel like a 90s adventure mystery game by Sierra.. Well boy do I have the desktop for you!

d1l 1 day ago | parent

The main difficulty I see in these "RETVRN TO SOVL" things is not the window-manager or desktop itself but the UI toolkits for the applications. GTK2 had so many excellent themes. Now GTK or libadwaita seem designed to resist themes and introduce constant breaking of selectors or widgets or whatnot. I believe they griefed the themers into just giving up. I have less knowledge about Qt, but I assume it's probably the better pick these days.

thwarted 1 day ago | parent

To say nothing of client side decorations, which diverge the user interface among apps and remove control from the user to globally customize some aspect of their application window management/theming.

TheAceOfHearts 1 day ago | parent

Earlier today I was reading through the KDE 6.8 release notes and I found out about Union [0][1], which is a unified theming system for QtQuick and QtWidgets using a single CSS source file. Hopefully this encourages a bit more creative experimentation, although I'm quite happy with the default theme at this point. It feel very comfy to me.

[0] https://quantumproductions.info/articles/2026-08/union-summe...

[1] https://akselmo.dev/posts/union-qtwidgets/

lostmsu 16 hours ago | parent

> CSS

cries

hobo123 1 day ago | parent

I believe Linux Mint forked Adwaita so they can implement theming with it.

silon42 1 day ago | parent

Or an alternative solution, fork to remove Adwaita.

whatever1 1 day ago | parent

This will be the chance of the Linux desktop to thrive.

In the past ui development was so hard and none of the app developers had the expertise or appetite to do it properly.

LLMs changed that overnight. A good engineer can build great UI for their app.

OroPla 1 day ago | parent

This looks like something that heavily relies on a pointer device and thus is the opposite of what I want. But it can probably work well for people not minding this detail. Might even work better in VR.

nxobject 1 day ago | parent

Welcome back, Microsoft Bob!

wang_li 1 day ago | parent

Skeuomorphism should make my life easier. But sometimes it goes against that. I want to have a button that prints my document, I don't want to have to operate a virtual letter press. Having a switch to turn something on and off that looks like a switch helps me. A screen door that is the lock activation isn't what I would expect.

MattCruikshank 1 day ago | parent

Looks like an 80s video game.

BigGreenJorts 1 day ago | parent

Love this so much. I've been thinking of trying to represent my notes in a way like this where categories of material are "stored together" not in folders, but "physical" items that represent the category like a globe for travel notes or a bookshelves of movie reviews etc.

ianeff 1 day ago | parent

Wrong abstraction! I love it… But wrong abstraction!

lnvdpwl 1 day ago | parent

Reminds me of the launcher I build in HyperCard when I was like 10 y/o. It consisted of some graphic of a desk an I could click different objects to run applications.

anajimi 1 day ago | parent

Amazing and beautiful, I love it! I'm working on something similar so it gives me ideas.

hackeraccount 1 day ago | parent

That's a no for me - it seems like it would be a bear to use for more then 5 minutes.

I'm not sure if I feel the same way about skeuomorphism as a general design philosophy. Maybe this is just the wrong metaphor?

HoldOnAMinute 1 day ago | parent

UI design peaked with Motif Window Manager and has gone downhill ever since.

inatreecrown2 1 day ago | parent

What a lovely project, going to try it later on a spare x230. I love to see a new floating window manager style, tiling is nice but floating too.

yldreader 1 day ago | parent

The entire concept of skeuomorphism on computers is nonsensical. A monitor has a default blank grey or black appearance. EVERYTHING else is skeuomorphic, including the ugly 'modern' color rectangles the people who use this word want to exempt.

wlonkly 1 day ago | parent

This reminds me of the Commodore 64 productivity software (on cartridge), Magic Desk:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magic_Desk

pmarreck 1 day ago | parent

Now where's the Metro-inspired one?

ngl999 1 day ago | parent

I like this kind of stuff but I think the analogy work the best around objects that are actually on the desk. Wardrobes or steampunk looking instrument is a bit too much.

webprofusion 1 day ago | parent

Like a 90s adventure game, just insert the CD-ROM.

hollowonepl 1 day ago | parent

Brilliant, I love it. Is there any video showing how it works in action?

drayfield 1 day ago | parent

Love the idea, but in reality this is a heavy AI-assisted project riddled with weird graphical issues that completely detract from the experience. It's less a window manager, and more akin to a mid-90's CD-ROM puzzle game. For instance having to turn a key to allow shutting down your machine is a cute idea but the key turn animation plays inconsistently, meaning the state of some of the buttons isn't always obvious.

forestingfisher 1 day ago | parent

Agree, but it has potential. If it was polished up a bit I would use it.

tfrancisl 1 day ago | parent

Agreed, looks very sloppy and unpolished. I was immediately turned away when i saw the recommended install method was `sudo sh` this random script.

deltarholamda 22 hours ago | parent

>more akin to a mid-90's CD-ROM puzzle game

"You can just say 'Myst', it's cleaner."

sylware 1 day ago | parent

DUDE!

VULKAN!

(and shaders written with a SPIR-V assembler, no glslang!)

hasley 1 day ago | parent

The idea is really nice. And I think projects like this could help elderly or mentally less gifted people.

Unfortunately, things break inside the programs. Usually the folder structure is still exposed as-is and the programs (except things like calculators or synthesizers) do not look like things from the physical world.

I have to do with some elderly people who do not have a mental model about file systems, program menus, tabs, and other things. They learn by heart where to click. And then they forget it when they do not use it on a regular basis. But they cannot regain this knowledge on their own since the UI has no inherent logic for them.

zaphar 1 day ago | parent

    Notifications arrive in a post box
This is genius. Absolute genius. There when you are ready to peruse but not in your face constantly.

miramba 23 hours ago | parent

Lovely. Can’t wait for this style to come into fashion again. Notes with yellowish backgrounds, game center with green velour like a roulette table, 3D-Buttons that render a click, I want it all back!

__natty__ 23 hours ago | parent

Welcome to the 2010. I love this design!

crazygringo 23 hours ago | parent

This is fun, but since when are calculators made out of paper...?

This actually makes me wonder what a desktop plus basic office suite would look like if it really tried to adhere to a physical object paradigm.

No windows at all. Instead, every e-mail is a folded piece of paper (inside of an envelope?) in a basket. Every word-processing document is just a stack of sheets. The tool palette in a paint program is actual tools scattered around the edges -- pencil, pen, bucket of paint.

It would score poorly for usability, but on the other hand, it feels like the kind of thing that could be vibe-coded for fun.

guerrilla 21 hours ago | parent

It's cute. I'd use it if it's stable. It reminds me of BeOS/Haiku for some reason.

martinambrus 18 hours ago | parent

gamifying Wayland, very nice :)