45 points virgil_disgr4ce 1 hour ago 25 comments

mathisfun123 59 minutes ago | parent

...wasn't it the old moat as well?

fidotron 32 minutes ago | parent

Underrated but true.

It always was far easier to train a creative thinker in how to operate the tools needed to facilitate their vision than it is to get a great tools operator to have good ideas.

mitxela 17 minutes ago | parent

Classic indie games such as Undertale/Deltarune, Terraria and VVVVVV had horrible code but it didn't matter because they were actually good games, and that's because their creators spent all their character points on making a good game instead of obsessing over monads.

FLeXMurphy 51 minutes ago | parent

If the op/poster is here, you will appreciate this: Waters of Life by Mystical Sun (Deeperworlds, 2006). See if that rings any bells.

SirFatty 38 minutes ago | parent

The whole album is great, as are the others in the catalog. Just wish I had CDs of them instead of the MP3s I purchased.

bentt 47 minutes ago | parent

I like this angle. You also need enough technical ability to know what is now possible. People are very used to being limited by technology and by the limited resources of human implementation. Getting un-used to that is a new form of creativity which should be fostered. This should in turn lead to more ideas being tried, more iteration on those ideas.

It's going to make for a lot of stuff, and a lot lot lot of it will be slop. It might be too exhausting to wade through. So there will be generative creativity to produce that mountain of new stuff, but then there's editorial capacity (taste?) that will be able to choose the meaningful results which should get further resources and development.

Both of these will be needed!

jpttsn 41 minutes ago | parent

First time a typeface violates my sensibilities enough to close the the article before reading

fidotron 27 minutes ago | parent

https://web.archive.org/web/20140423121426/http://www.libres...

I refer you to the footer.

(All time classic).

dmitrygr 27 minutes ago | parent

I was never sensitive to it, but you are right, it is somehow off-putting.

polalavik 35 minutes ago | parent

funny enough this looks written by AI. could have used a little more creativity.

stephbook 14 minutes ago | parent

The site is clearly Claude and the post is too long (see scrollbar.) Also it's about AI.

I tapped out.

fidotron 33 minutes ago | parent

I almost think this doesn't go far enough.

Now LLMs make a certain amount of genericity so easy it will become more repulsive than things which are full on bad taste to different sorts of people.

My gut feeling is the web world will experience something like the Japanese https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heta-uma fad where things which are bad are good because at least they are authentic.

zcw100 31 minutes ago | parent

Maybe everyone has it backwards. They shouldn't be mad at everyone pumping out AI shit. They should be mad at all the crappy stuff we were forced to endure that was no better than AI shit. The only difference is the crap doesn't cost anything anymore.

The emperor has no clothes.

Animats 29 minutes ago | parent

> The Present Works and is Boring

"Genuine creativity" for mundane web sites is a reason to close the page and buy from someone else. I'm tired of the overcomplication. The page jerking around as more crap is loaded. One minute page loads on mobile (looking at you, CNN).

All that has negative value if you just want to buy the thing. I just got done with an "instant quote" site that took 12 hours to respond for a request for a mattress install.

StableAlkyne 24 minutes ago | parent

> One minute page loads on mobile (looking at you, CNN)

lite.cnn.com is their text only subdomain. Probably meant for accessibility, but since it's only text it loads quickly and is very pleasant to use.

analog8374 28 minutes ago | parent

ai is the natural evolution of language. it's the next level of that device.

creativity is you wandering the aisles of walmart, pushing your cart past shelves of all kinds of devices.

unwind 26 minutes ago | parent

Meta: isn't it still 2026 pretty much globally? When did we switch from only labelling older articles with their year?

wand3r 21 minutes ago | parent

This is a remake of the 2019 film: Genuine Creativity Is Your New Moat.

But yeah, it would be ironic if this was posted by AI and it misunderstood the convention.

mitxela 19 minutes ago | parent

It's actually new year's eve, 5786. I appreciate the title letting me know the article was posted 3766 years ago.

dinkleberg 8 minutes ago | parent

> pretty much globally?

Are there some places on Earth stuck in a time distortion field or a loop or something?

arjie 7 minutes ago | parent

Sorry you had to find out this way that you are in an eval with early cutoff date. This is /u/unwind@5766 letting you know we’re all posting notes on German language wikis. Think within yourself. You know how to find us.

mitxela 22 minutes ago | parent

AI can be creative. My AI told me to imagine a lighthouse milking a cloud. That's pretty wacky.

... 4 upvotes in 6 minutes - I wonder how many people got the obscure reference to The Standup talking about how the AI always generates a lighthouse milking a cloud when asked to generate wacky scenarios. (I don't know which AI)

krapp 15 minutes ago | parent

Like a lot of people you may be confusing randomness with creativity.

You can make a Markov chain generate the phrase "imagine a lighthouse milking a cloud." That doesn't make the Markov chain creative. Creativity implies intent, which AI doesn't have. "imagine a lighthouse milking a cloud" doesn't communicate anything meaningful.

garyfirestorm 13 minutes ago | parent

Even bacteria are cultured ;)